RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver Reviews

RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver logo

RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver

RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver, 1658 Cole Blvd #290, Lakewood, CO 80401

3.7 113 verified reviews

Renosy by Renters Warehouse Denver is a third-party property management company offering full-service management for Denver-area rental properties (single-family focus indicated by references to single-family homes and a Denver market). Distinct differentiators include a fixed monthly management rate per property, no marketing or upfront fees, cancel-anytime policy, 24/7 maintenance, owner portal, and a focus on tenant placement with advanced screening tools.

Is this your company?
Claim this page for free to update your details, answer reviews, and get landlord requests.
Claim it free

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.1 / 5
from 30 owners
Tenant Rating
3.5 / 5
from 83 tenants
High confidence · 30 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver photo RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver photo RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver photo RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver photo RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver photo RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
158
4 star
5
3 star
0
2 star
3
1 star
47

Based on 213 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

RENOSY by Renters Warehouse Denver reviews

5.0★May 2026

This week, I got several reminders of how lucky me and my family are to have discovered Rhino Tongol and the rest of the team at Renters Warehouse. In the last week, they've repaired electricity at one property, taken care of Section 8 paperwork and inspection at another, and then finished the week by installing a ceiling fan and lights at another. Back when me and my family tried to manage these properties, they were expensive migraines with high turnover. Ever since the Renters Warehouse team took over, they turned these properties into profitable investments that are in great shape and f…

1.0★Apr 2026

We retained the company to lease a brand new ADU in Denver. New tenant, yay! However, during that process, we tried to retain them to lease another unit and three weeks later it is still not on the market. We have answered the same questions multiple times and today, we gave up, went to our old leasing agent and the property is already on line and listed for rent. This potentially cost us a full month of rent, we can never recover! When our new tenant moved in, the keys we left for the tenant had gone missing, creating a huge inconvenience for them and now we need to rekey the unit for their …

1.0★Apr 2026

I’m completely shocked how this company treats there homeowners, terrible customer service, and Their staff do not know their own contract agreements between homeowner and tenants. First off they kept sending sensitive emails to the wrong person at multiple times in this past year. If you are a homeowner in the Denver area do not use this company for property management. They are incompetent, and if I can give them zero stars I would.

5.0★Mar 2026

Rhino Tongol with Renters Warehouse was great. Fast, efficient and friendly. My experience with this company as an owner has been great from start to finish.

1.0★Mar 2026

They never have the right answer no one ever returns your call you leave messages no 1 returns your messages it's a terrible company do not rent from here If you do talk to someone record your conversations because one person says one thing and then another says you get the picture

5.0★Mar 2026

I had a great experience with Jayme. He helped me to understand how to interpret the Owner Ledger and helped me obtain a duplicate 1099. He was very patient and knowledgeable.

5.0★Nov 2025

Tim Emery at renters' warehouse has been such a great PM for us. Not only is his follow through outstanding but his proactive approach in helping us serve our tenants is second to none. I would highly recommend Tim and renter's warehouse.

2.0★Jun 2025

So, we changed our review rating because up until getting our tenants moved in, we felt that we truly had a property manager. In fact, even his boss, Kirby, was following up. However, based on our experience, once the tenants are settled in, all communication goes through a ticket portal system. Email responses to who we thought was our personal property manager are either ignored or days late. By the way, we moved to Germany and so we are relying on RW to provide hands-on oversight while we are away for 2+ years. Last month our tenants were asked to submit an emergency ticket (#00698268) thr…

5.0★May 2025

The best company to help you rent out your property, offering services tailored specifically to meet your needs."

5.0★May 2025

Gavin worked his tail off to find a tenant for our property. He communicated in a timely manner and only what was necessary. Very professional experience up to this point...

5.0★Apr 2025

Kirby and his team are great to work with. I’ve rented from them and now am working with them to purchase a home. They are very helpful and knowledgable about the process. Highly recommended!

5.0★Apr 2025

Gavin has been my guy since day 1. Started renting my home with Gavin and renters warehouse and the experience has been nothing but easy, fast and professional. First time landlord and Gavin has been with me every step of the way aiding me and explaining every step of the process. Highly recommend giving Gavin a call if you're looking for a property manager!

5.0★Apr 2025

Gavin is highly recommended. He is extremely knowledgable about the market and takes a consultative approach to help guide his clients through the market. He's also very on top of it and is proactive with his communications and updates. He just placed a new tenant for me with zero vacancy. I'm very confident with Gavin managing my property!

5.0★Apr 2025

As a rental owner, Renter’s Warehouse made the process of filling a vacancy quick and seamless. Kirby and his team are top notch.

1.0★Mar 2025

Working with Jerry Kagarise of Renters Warehouse initially felt like a breath of fresh air after a devastating experience with my previous property management company. My property had been left vacant too long and in poor condition, and I was beginning to lose hope. Jerry turned things around quickly—he was proactive, detail-oriented, communicative, and placed a qualified tenant on a 2-year lease. At that point, I truly felt confident in RW’s ability to manage my property. Update after 3 months: Unfortunately, my positive experience ended there. Jerry was not actually my property manager and …

5.0★Feb 2025

I enjoyed working with Logan. He was very professional and kept me informed about potential renters. It took awhile, but it was winter and the market was slower. I'm very pleased with my new tenants.

5.0★Nov 2024

I had a fantastic experience working with Jesse to lease my property. They were professional, responsive, and made the entire process seamless. From marketing the property to handling tenant inquiries, Jesse took care of every detail with expertise and efficiency. Thanks to their efforts, I found the perfect tenant quickly. I highly recommend Jesse for anyone looking to lease a property—excellent service all around!

5.0★Aug 2024

Gavin is awesome! Outstanding service! Smoothly walked me through the process of first time landlord. Found an applicant for our place just in 5 days. I highly recommend Gavin and RW, in case you'd need to hire property management company.

5.0★Jul 2024

Amazing customer service - Jesse Sellers!! From the initial phone call / introduction through today as I post this, Jesse has gone above and beyond what any property manager we've used have done. From prepping the property, tenant placement and supporting us to provide a great experience to the tenant, the process couldn't have been smoother. Whether you're new to the rental market or looking for more support, Renters Warehouse has been the best PM experience we've ever had. Highly recommend Jesse and his team, make sure to include him in your due diligence when selecting a property manage…

5.0★Jul 2024

This is my first time renting my home and Gavin has been exceptional so far as a property manager. He found the correct tenant for my property in a timely and professional matter, and the process has gone very well thus far. We have just started on our 17 month rental so hopefully everything goes as smoothly as it has so far. Would highly recommend Gavin and Renters Warehouse. I will leave another review when our 17 months are up, but I'm confident it will be another 5 star!

5.0★Jun 2024

Gavin Kelly was awesome in the assisting in rehabbing my property. Quickly found me a tenant and increased my gross rents. I'm very pleased.

5.0★Jun 2024

Ben Beaty was of great help in renting our unit. He promptly scheduled a review of the unit, pointed out details that needed to be addressed, clearly explained the process and made suggestions for the showings. Ben took care of doing all the photos of the unit and provided us with all the documents in a timely manner and was able to get the unit under rental agreement all within two days. Thank you for your help, Ben.

5.0★Jun 2024

I have been working with Gavin Kelly and am highly impressed by his professionalism and communication skills. He is always available and consistently represents me effectively to tenants. Gavin ensures all communications are clear and prompt, making him an invaluable asset.

5.0★Jun 2024

Gavin Kelly did a great job representing the owner. Whenever we asked for something he was able to contact the owner and we got an answer in minutes. He was very professional and he gets 5 stars and two thumbs up from me.

5.0★May 2024

Gavin Kelly with Renters Warehouse has made owning a rental property a stress-free experience. Gavin is professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about my investment. Highly recommend!

5.0★Apr 2024

Gavin Kelly was outstanding! Absolutely 5 star! Gavin reached out to us within a day of our initial inquiry. He offered information and assistance and explained our options in detail. He made choosing Renters Warehouse and easy choice. He found us multiple tenant options quickly, and we found an ideal tenant! My wife and I live out of state and Gavin made us feel very comfortable with every step of the process. If you're looking to rent your home, Gavin and Renters Warehouse are the way to go!

5.0★Mar 2024

My Rent Estate professional was Gavin Kelly. I initally was a Renters Warehouse customer back in 2016 rentinging my property with Renters Warehouse. They made it look easy, so after a couple of years I thought I could do what they do and I could save some money. Big mistake! I'm back now and Gavin Kelly, my agent, worked diligently and made me feel like I was his only customer, and I know I was not. He is smart and knows what he is doing and got me a 2-year lease at what I was asking for and he found tenants quickly! I'm retired now and really did not want to worry about the day to day rentin…

5.0★Mar 2024

Thank you Luke Scholtz and Gavin Kelly for always being so helpful and responsive. Renters Warehouse helped us get great tenants and they just renewed their lease!

1.0★Feb 2024

I'll start with the fact I used RW for finding tenants, and "property management" for 3 years, after that, I'm not even sure where to begin. I guess the 1 star is the fact that they did find me two good renters. With that being said, 1 star is generous. I used them for far too long. Insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results. 1. I was told I'd have a person who would basically manage the rental locally, which was a complete lie. The sales person washed their hands of us as soon as it was rented out. Well, that was until it was time to renew. The managers are not i…

1.0★Nov 2023

Mariana is the worst manger with no personal connection , every thing she need to do it’s take forever . If you have emergency it will take few days just to start to move thing . She will tell you that she will call back and it’s never happened she will not call you back and she will let you wait so long . And will tell you this is the process. And things that if you will do it by yourself it will take few hours max , but you will not get approve to do it because she want you to wait and wait and wait until you lose it . If you like your property and care about your tenants try to find dif…