McNeil Management Services Reviews

McNeil Management Services logo

McNeil Management Services

McNeil Management Services, 1463 Oakfield Dr #142, Brandon, FL 33511

3.3 9 verified reviews

McNeil Management specializes in HOA management for single-family residential, townhome, and villa communities in Hillsborough and Manatee County, offering a homeowner portal for easy management.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
3.0 / 5
from 7 owners
Tenant Rating
4.2 / 5
from 2 tenants
Medium confidence · 7 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Rating breakdown

5 star
3
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
1
1 star
8

Based on 12 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

McNeil Management Services reviews

5.0★May 2026

Excellent company, with friendly and professional members/staff who take care of the community.

1.0★Jul 2025

They are the worst! They definitely don't know how to manage. They send letters to people that aren’t offenders and don’t send to those that are definitely breaking all rules!!!

1.0★Apr 2025

If I could leave 0 stars I would. The HOA fees have almost doubled since I purchased my home in 21’. They won’t say where exactly the money goes. An example, “Landscaping enhancements- $4400 for the year” yet Southern Oaks Grove still looks like crap. Landscaping on a bi-monthly service costs almost $29000 for the year. How? Not to mention that we are having to pay for the builders original screw up of the retention ponds. Lastly, Jeff is completely incompetent and no one picks up the phone.

1.0★Jan 2025

McNeil Management Review: 0/5 Stars If I could give zero stars, I would. McNeil Management is running Boyette Creek in Riverview into the ground. I’m shocked they’re still in business. The community is plagued by constant issues with cars parked on sidewalks and streets, making it nearly impossible to drive or even reach your home. Despite countless complaints, management has done nothing to address this. Paying HOA fees is a nightmare. Their system seems intentionally difficult, leading to missed payments. And if you miss one? Get ready for $500 in outrageous lawyer fees! This feels less li…

1.0★Oct 2024

Abandoned vehicles parked up and down the street ain front of my house and nothing is being done about itisntthatwhy i pay monthly fees to have my house look like a junk yard isn’t that the point of an hoa to Inforce the rules terrible management company

1.0★Aug 2024

Living in a community where homes are valued at over $300,000 yet residents park on their lawns is quite concerning. This behavior detracts from the overall value of the neighborhood, which is evident to anyone observing the situation. It seems that McNeil Management expects homeowners to continue paying HOA fees while some residents treat their lawns as parking spaces. This is a significant issue for me, and I am considering selling my home due to these ongoing problems. I refuse to pay HOA dues to reside in an area that feels neglected. I had the impression that McNeil Management priorit…

1.0★Mar 2024

If there was ever a need for negative stars it would be needed 10000000 times over for McNeil non-management services. The owner came to our meeting last night and made it crystal clear they do not have the communities interests in mind. Awful, horrible, deceptive, nonhuman garbage. Absolutely disgusting. My sole life’s goal is to get rid of this trash and never look back! Be ashamed, close your doors!