Secure Door Property Management Reviews

Secure Door Property Management logo

Secure Door Property Management

Secure Door Property Management, 8065 S Beneva Rd Ste 7, Sarasota, FL 34238

4.2 15 verified reviews

Secure Door Property Management specializes in full-service property management in Sarasota and surrounding counties, offering multiple guarantees including a 21-day tenant placement guarantee and eviction protection.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.2 / 5
from 11 owners
Tenant Rating
4.3 / 5
from 4 tenants
High confidence · 11 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo Secure Door Property Management photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
27
4 star
1
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
2

Based on 30 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Secure Door Property Management reviews

5.0★May 2026

We hired Andrew as our property manager in Sarasota, Florida. He found tenants for our property within a month. Everything is still very new, but things are going smooth and we are very happy with his services.

5.0★Apr 2026

Secure Door Property Management has been a great experience from the start. Their team is professional, responsive, and truly understands what property owners need when it comes to reliable property management.

1.0★Oct 2025

Worst experience ever poor communication. Poor tenants screening. Unethical behavior . Bad business for landlords. I would not hire them. I would not rate them.

5.0★Sep 2025

I am so grateful for Secure Door Property Management, they go way beyond what you ask them to do. They are such a blessing to us. I would recommen them to any one who is looking for a very good property management. Our property manager Allen is the best. Bill

5.0★Aug 2025

I am very please with the professional and thorough service Secure Door Property Management offered. I am new to Venice and hired them to list my new home. The photos were beautiful and everything was explained to me in detail. I would highly recommend them if you’re looking to relax and let someone do all the heavy lifting. I had Airbnb properties for years and did everything myself. I didn’t want the hassle while living out retirement in sunny Florida.

1.0★Feb 2025

In my opinion, one of the worst companies to represent you when you pay them to represent you and they fail you

5.0★Aug 2024

Alan Myhre was my property manager, and is one of the best I've ever seen. I wouldn't hesitate to use his services again. Many of us have heard the property manager horror stories ... where you trust one or pay one, and they do nothing (except collect the fee). Alan is the opposite. I contracted with him to find a tenant for my rental unit. He started with a thorough inspection and inventory, and actually read the HOA's documents. He posted his own ad with his own photos, and found a number of prospects despite there being a slow market. I think he landed a very good tenant for me, though time…

5.0★Oct 2023

After having some issues with my previous property managers, I found secure door and have been very happy with them. They manage seven of my properties. Some of the properties were in bad shape when they took over, but they were prompt and did what it took to bring them up to standards for renting. Great communication and very prompt with any issues that may come up, I would recommend them to anyone looking for property managers.

5.0★Oct 2023

The team did a great job managing the tenant and repairs.

5.0★Oct 2023

I live across the country and having a responsive and competent property manager is a must. It’s such a relief to know I don’t have to worry because the staff and service at Secure Door is so professional and effective.

5.0★Oct 2023

Secure Door operates in a most efficient and professional manner in all aspects of their services. Our inquiries and concerns were given prompt attention as we began the process of being first time landlords of a rental property. We have been given the courtesy of an individualized process to resolving issues that arise with rental properties. One example of an issue is when a repair is needed. We are informed immediately and asked to clarify our preference to have Secure Door resolve the issue or to arrange for the repair ourselves. Communication by phone or email is immediate and our opin…