Eaton Realty | Local Realtors & Property Management Reviews

We were extremely pleased with Kara Baer's professional and friendly support, advice, and assistance throughout the process of preparing our beloved FishHawk Ranch home of 19 years, for sale and then the actual negotiation, execution and transaction. We sold our house for asking price - IN UNDER A MONTH from date of sale posting: that's proof in the pudding, reflecting Kara's stellar performance! Kara organized and ran a well-attended weekend open house just days after listing, and had a significant group of buyers on site, even competing with holiday weekend festivities. Almost immediatel…

We had an excellent experience working with Rebecca Kelly and Michelle Gailey at Eaton Realty. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions and wanted to be thoughtful and thorough throughout the process. Rebecca and Michelle were incredibly helpful from start to finish. Rebecca brought a tremendous amount of experience, practical guidance, and market insight. She helped us think through offer strategy, negotiation, inspection concerns, contract terms, and the many details that come up between going under contract and closing. Her advice was direct, knowledgeable, and valuable at each …

I very highly recommend Abby and Eaton Realty for your real estate needs! Abby was incredibly professional in all aspects of my parents home purchase. She handled all of the nuances that came with the home search, offer, inspection, and closing process. She made the process seem effortless, even when challenges arose. We are very grateful for her guidance and preparedness, and my parents wouldn’t be happily in their new home without her!

Rebecca (Becky) with Eaton Realty is exactly what you want in your corner when selling a home—action-oriented, detail-focused, communicative, transparent, and highly market-savvy. We went from listing to sale in about 5 months—faster than many comparable homes in Fishhawk Ranch. Becky understands that it’s you vs. the market, and she knows how to position you to win. I always recommend meeting multiple agents for a decision this important—but Rebecca should absolutely be one of them. This comes from someone who has both sold homes and trained real estate agents. We’ve also worked with Eaton…

If you’re looking for a property management experience where you actually feel valued, look no further than David Jordy and the team at Eaton Realty. From start to finish, David went above and beyond in ways that are genuinely rare in this industry. He was responsive, proactive, and consistently made me feel like a priority — not just another name on a list. What sets David apart is that he actually listens. He took the time to understand what mattered to us and made sure every step of the process reflected that. And it wasn’t just him — the entire Eaton Realty team carries that same culture …

As a long time property owner and investor, I've worked with numerous realtors of the years in various markets. I normally work with realtors that come recommended. Even then, it becomes pretty evident pretty quickly which realtors are good, which ones are mediocre and which ones are just plain bad.  While I didn't work with Karissa very long (before we found a house that we closed on) it was apparent right from the get-go that she was an exceptional realtor. My most recent situation was buying a property with two friends. Why I mention this is because the more people involved, the harder it i…

We had a fantastic experience with Eaton Realty. We rented one of their homes for about two years before eventually working with their team to purchase a house, so we’ve seen both sides of what they offer as a property manager and as a real estate brokerage. As a landlord, Eaton Realty was great to work with. The home they offered was a much better fit for our needs and noticeably nicer than a lot of other options on the market at the time. They were responsive, professional, and easy to work with throughout the entire rental period. When it came time to buy a home, it made perfect sense to …

Karissa was absolutely fantastic to work with. I can’t do her justice in this review - but trust me when I say she works tirelessly for you. She leaves no stone unturned when it comes to potential properties, and she ensures that your wants and needs are letting mind with each choice. We were absolutely a complex client, and I cannot thank her enough for her patience and understanding. She is kind, knowledgeable, prompt, responsive, and genuinely cares for her clients. I cannot recommend her enough!

I had a great experience working with Eaton Realty. Tim Trimbath was professional, responsive, and very easy to work with from start to finish. They handled everything smoothly, from preparing and marketing the property to getting it rented quickly. Communication was clear throughout the process, which gave me real peace of mind as a property owner. I highly recommend Eaton Realty to anyone looking for reliable property management.

We have received property management services from 2017 through 2022. We then lived at our place for 3 years after before finally selling through Eaton as well. Every one of their staff is professional and highly knowledgeable. I would not go with any other company in the Tampa region. This company has high standards for properties they manage so people will get quality places to rent. If we ever come to a cross roads of either renting out or selling our current place, Eaton will get our business.

Kara Baer was recommended to us to help with our search for a rental 2 years ago. She sent us multiple suggestions but ultimately we wound up moving into an apartment. Fast forward to today we PURCHASED OUR NEW HOME!!! Kara’s expertise, responsiveness and attention to detail made what can often be a stressful process fell smooth and manageable. I especially appreciated how she took notes for us during our final walk through and her calm and confident demeanor. We wouldn’t hesitate to work with her again or to recommend her to anyone in need of a top notch real estate professional.

We're so grateful to have met Rebecca Kelly 11 years ago when we moved to Fishhawk. She helped us purchase our home, and then 11 years later helped us sell it. She's a subject matter expert who made the process of buying and selling our home seamless. It's such an advantage in a market like this to have someone with the experience and knowledge of the area. Of all the realtors in the area, Rebecca is my top choice. Thank you!

We struggled for years to own a home. Did everything in our power to try to get our credit up and have money to purchase a home. Every lender we spoke to kept telling us to keep raising our credit even when we would get it to a point they asked. It was an endless cycle. We went to look at a property on Zillow and Karissa Coyle from Eaton was the one who came to show the house. In that moment I didn’t realize how much our life’s would change in such a short time. She was very straight forward and not pushy felt amazing to have someone who was honest and real with us. She helped us find a lender…

Kara did an amazing job guiding us through the entire rental process as we relocated from another state. Her patience, clear communication, and attention to detail made what could have been a stressful experience smooth and stress-free. We truly appreciate all her hard work and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a rental.

Excellent service! They fixed the AC in our master bedroom quickly and professionally. The technician arrived on time, explained the issue clearly, and had everything working perfectly before leaving. The room is now cooling much better than before. I really appreciate the quality of the work and the friendly customer service. Highly recommended!

I cannot say enough great things about Kara Baer! When we first moved to Florida a year ago, we were unfamiliar with the area and needed help finding the right rental property. Kara was very knowledgable about the area and was genuinely invested in helping us find a place that fit our needs. When we were finally ready to purchase a home, Kara was up for the challenge of finding us a home with exactly what we wanted in the exact area we wanted to live in. She has been every professional and responsive throughout the whole home buying process despite the annoyances that went with it. We would hi…

Rebecca Kelly helped to make the stress of selling a home so much easier. Her vast real estate knowledge and trade contacts were invaluable. Rebecca was amazing at communicating feedback from buyers and other agents, and always kept us in the loop of every facet of the home selling process. She has spoiled us for any other realtor! We highly recommend Rebecca!

I worked with Christine Smith at Eaton to help find a rental for my family and then again for my mother. She communicated and walked us through every step of the way and still checks up on us every rentaversary. She will always be our agent!

The team at Eaton was a huge help with navigating the application and move in process at my new place. They were very patient and informative explaining things to me when I had questions about the process. Always available and a good bunch, highly recommend!

Working with Eaton Realty was a great experience from start to finish. When I first reached out, their team responded quickly and immediately helped by sharing multiple rental options that fit what I was looking for. The entire process felt organized, smooth, and supportive, which made a stressful move feel much more manageable. I especially want to recognize Kara for being amazing throughout the process. She was flexible, accommodating, communicative, and always willing to work with my schedule. She consistently checked back in, kept me updated, answered my questions quickly, and made me fee…

Our property manager Ashley goes above and beyond with any request we have had after moving into our new place a bit over a month ago. I am thankful that she’s been here to make the transition as smooth as possible.

Awful experience working with Leah Johnson¡¡ No feedback, no reports on my property until I asked for it. I want to cancel and they charge me $1490 usd to let my house free and I need to go to the office to drop the check. Awful awful experience¡¡¡¡¡

Eaton Realty has been absolutely amazing. My partner and I went through them to rent our first place together, and everyone that we’ve interacted with on the team has been extremely kind and helpful. Susan Walker is the realtor who showed us the place we wanted to tour and she helped us throughout the process any time we needed, she’s great. Ashley Seiferheld is our property manager now and she’s amazing as well. She’s very kind and helpful, and was extremely accommodating with getting us set up and working around our schedules. She really goes above and beyond for her clients. Edgar Rios help…

RENTERS BEWARE: Eaton Realty does not properly calculate debt-to-income ratio during the application process. Edgar sent the following criteria to me: "DTI < 50%: Applicants must have a combined gross income (including rental income, alimony, child support, investment dividends, etc.) of at least two times their combined monthly expenses (including proposed rent, current mortgages, car loans, credit card payments, alimony, child support, etc.). We reserve the right to require a co-signer. A minimum of two years of residential rental history is required." DTI is supposed to reflect CURRENT, V…

I just leased a home through them, and the experience was seamless. Daniel Rodriguez was the realtor who showed me the home and guided me through the application process. From start to finish, everything was completed in just two days. Daniel showed me the house the same day I inquired, which I really appreciated. Working with them has been easy and efficient.

Im extatic to say that we were able to find the perfect home with Daniel Rodriguez. He really listened and made sure that we got everything that were asking for at the best price. He is very professional and answers all our questions that we asked him. He is very respectful and tentative. It was nice to feel as an active duty military member that my house searching process was so smooth and stress free because of having Daniel working with us and understanding how stressful it can be while moving in the Military to a new unit. Thank you Daniel for all your help from our family to yours.

Working with Abby was an absolute pleasure from the beginning ! She took the time to truly understand what we were looking for. Never gave up on us. We are still In the application process, but the process was very smooth ! She has been super nice , clear , friendly and we never felt left in the dark ! I can’t recommend Abby enough to anyone looking to buy or sell a home !

Thank you Tim!! for all the hard work and dedication you put into managing our property. Your professionalism and attention to detail truly make a difference, and we really appreciate everything you do. Muchas Gracias !

Abby was very helpful, responsive and guided the process with ease. Would highly recommend her.

Five stars all the way! Ashley has gone above and beyond to make my family and I feel so special when renting our home! I love the ocasional check ins & always making sure we are aware that we can reach out with any questions or concerns! This whole process has been amazingly simple thanks to this great team! Thanks for you all you! Another five stars goes to Christine! Christine has always been just a phone call away, super attentive, knowledgeable & kind as well! When renting our first home with Eaton Reality Christine made the process so simple and was there every step of the way! She made…

The entire Eaton Realty team and especially Kaylie were incredibly professional, thorough and responsive. As a testament to the classiness of the company and especially Kaylie There was an Additional supplement added to the security deposit given an inconvenience that happened while we were not at the house prior to the end of our lease. That type of service and consideration makes this company different from others. Cannot thank enough how Eaton Realty and Kaylie handled our lease. Classy organization, and even better people.

I had an amazing experience working with Christine, Edgar, and Ashley. They made the entire process incredibly smooth and stress-free while helping me move into my new place. From start to finish, they were professional, responsive, and truly had my best interest in mind. They were always available to answer questions, kept everything organized, and made what can be a stressful process feel easy and seamless. You can tell they genuinely care about their clients and take pride in what they do. I highly recommend Christine, Edgar, and Ashley to anyone looking for a reliable, knowledgeable, and s…

Alison Espinoza truly was a godsend. We were selling our home in New York while simultaneously searching for our ideal home in the Tampa area, which felt overwhelming at times. The distance, timing, and big decisions made the process stressful and uncertain. "Alie" guided us to success with incredible patience, kindness, and knowledge. She took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for, kept us informed every step of the way, and made a complicated long-distance move feel manageable. Her professionalism and genuine care gave us confidence throughout the process, and we couldn’t b…

I’ve been gratefully able to work with Ashley and Edgar. They are both prompt and diligent in answering questions and have been very helpful.

We’ve had a wonderful experience renting through Eaton Realty. After having some very difficult experiences with previous rental companies, working with Eaton Realty—especially Ashley Seiferheld—has truly been a breath of fresh air. From the moment we moved in, Ashley has been extremely attentive, responsive, and genuinely helpful. Any issues we’ve had as tenants have been handled quickly and professionally, which has made renting here stress-free and positive. We’re very grateful for her dedication and highly recommend Eaton Realty!

I was helped by Susan Walker and I have to say I am so pleased and grateful for her help. She went above and beyond for my needs and listened to what was important to me for finding a home staying within my budget. I recommend Susan to anyone who is looking for a home/apartment! You will not be disappointed!

We had a great experience working with Eaton. Everything went very smoothly from start to finish. A special thank-you to Julie Krock for her patience and professionalism—she was wonderful to work with and even waited an hour for us when we were running late to our showing. Highly recommend!

Kara Bear was absolutely wonderful to work with! She went above and beyond to help us secure our rental and stayed in touch with us every step of the way. Kara was so kind and thoughtful ; even offering to help when we were moving in and surprising us with a pumpkin for Halloween! We’re so grateful for all her help and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor. We can’t wait to work with her again when it’s time to buy our home!

Kara did a great job in helping us to buy a house. Highly recommended for anyone that is looking to buy house.

When my wife and I were looking to sell our Fishhawk home, we took a few days to talk with a few different brokerages and agents in the area before making a decision. Susan Walker was by far the stand out choice for us from the moment she walked through our front door. Susan came into our house on day one full of knowledge, excitement and gracious professionalism that made our decision easy to go with her and Eaton Realty. Throughout the selling process she kept us informed and updated with constant communication and leads she was actively searching and reaching out for. She made it clear she …

I can’t speak highly enough of Kara Baer from Eaton Realty - the best real estate agent we could have asked for. As a long distance homebuyers it was crucial for us to find an agent who was not only very knowledgeable and experienced but also someone we could trust to listen to our needs and have our best interest at heart. Kara Baer was a true blessing, she exceeded all our expectations! She didn’t just email us listings that met our criteria, but also made sure to point out the pros and cons of each property. She invited us to join her via FaceTime to view homes and always took the time to a…

Abby was an exceptional Real Estate agent. She followed through on every single issue that came regarding the sale, and solved very simply anything that presented itself during the process. I recommend her with the very highest recommendation.

My property manager Ashley was the utmost professional in executing her duties when I moved into my house. The tour, inspection even welcome basket were top notch. I expected as much from a member of Eaton Realty. I’m a return customer and will continue to be one with Eaton having teammates like Ashley.

We had a wonderful experience with Eaton Realty. Specifically with Alison Espinoza. We worked with Alie to find the perfect home for us. She would check out listenings for us (as we lived over 2 hours away) and would give her honest feedback on the home. Not only did Alie have our best interests at heart but she was a joy to work with and has a great sense of humor. Highly recommend her.

Superb Realtor - we had a lot of questions for Kara and she answered every single one. She cares a lot about her customers, Thank you!

We rented a townhouse in Apollo Beach through Eaton, and it was a great experience for us! Eaton was professional and timely in handling all of our maintenance requests. A special thanks to Keely, our property manager, who was always helpful and responsive with any inquiries we had.

From the initial showing of the home to our orientation on move in day, Christine & Keely were a pleasure to work with and made the process so easy for us! Eaton has a very high standard for how their properties are kept and we couldn’t be happier with our new home. Thank you both so much!

I had an amazing experience with Eaton Realty and Abby Rothrock! She listens, works with you, and explains everything they do as a team to help you through this process. She helped me see the value in price point, we all have numbers stuck in our head, and she educated me on the importance of this to where it should be to sell, and it did!! I loved working with the team. They were very communicative, professional, and the whole process couldn’t have been easier. they made what could’ve been a stressful experience very easy for me. Thank you!

My daughter and I purchased a house from Carissa in September last year and she is the most personable lady I have ever met. She is so sweet. You would be very satisfied if you had her for your realtor.

The staff at Eaton Realty are some of the most genuine, kind, and generous people you will ever meet. We struggled for weeks to find a place that suited our needs and that didn’t go off market the second we requested a viewing. Kara Baer is incredible - she invested time in getting to know us and she not only found the perfect home for us in a matter of hours, but helped guide us step by step through the process of securing it. She also went out of her way to thoughtfully and personally welcome us to our new home when we officially received our keys. Keely Jones greeted us to our new home like…

Tim Trimbath did an outstanding job helping me through my inspection at the property that I was renting. He was absolutely great to work with. Tim took the time to answer any questions and provided me with all options available. Tim was professional, courteous, kind and took the stress out of moving by keeping things light and fun, while getting the work done. I'd give 5+ star to Tim if I could. Thank you Tim for your immeasurable patience and your great humor!

Eaton Realty has been amazing so far!! Michael Poggi , Janna Daugherty, Daniel Rothrock, Keely Jones and Leah were just fantastic. They were extremely professional, proficient and super quick with finding us the perfect tenants for our property. Our process of renting out was so stress free and fast! Eaton Realty has definitely raised their bar for all other property management companies. I recommend Eaton Realty for all your real estate needs.