Palm Island Realty Property Management Reviews

Palm Island Realty Property Management logo

Palm Island Realty Property Management

Palm Island Realty Property Management, 1406 N Dale Mabry Hwy #200, Tampa, FL 33607

3.2 6 verified reviews

Third-party property management in Florida focusing on single-family homes, condos, and duplexes with an owner portal and online payments; over 17 years in Tampa Bay and Pensacola, managing a large portfolio including over 450 single-family homes, apartments, condos, and duplexes, and offering Rhino security deposit alternative.

Is this your company?
Claim this page for free to update your details, answer reviews, and get landlord requests.
Claim it free

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.4 / 5
no owner reviews
Tenant Rating
3.2 / 5
from 6 tenants
Not yet rated by landlords

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Fees & business details

From Palm Island Realty Property Management’s website. Confirm current pricing with the company.

Years in business17

Photos

Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo Palm Island Realty Property Management photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
7
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
7

Based on 14 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Palm Island Realty Property Management reviews

5.0★Dec 2025

I just recently moved into the new property, the depiction of the property on the company site was not only accurate, but very well pictured. The staff was quick to reply and answer any questions I had. Marie and Maggie helped me from beginning to end. They helped things move along quickly and didn’t skip a beat, and both are very professional and friendly.

1.0★Aug 2025

Marie actively will lie and gaslight. They lie about sending emails. They do not send any sort of instructions or warnings for moving out. They send AC people out who never fix the problems. They put phoney charges on your account after you move out. And regardless of how often you call and try to talk to anybody in management they will not give you a voicemail and they will not let you talk to anybody. They will hang up the phone on you numerous times.

1.0★Mar 2025

Don’t use these people they are fraud they took my nieces deposit and on the day of her move in date they told her that she couldn’t move in after they told her everything was good and ready for move in. They are fraud they take your money and than tell u you were not approved

1.0★Feb 2025

Applied for a small home that had been listed on Zillow for rent for 50+ days. My wife and I have decent credit. However We lived with a roommate who stopped sending our money each month to our landlord (2 land lords ago) and we almost got evicted. If it wasn’t for my wife and I using all of the money we set aside for our honey moon we would’ve been homeless.. but we did and the eviction got fully dismissed. I have documentation to prove it was dismissed, I have documentation from the landlord saying they received the funds.. we stayed an additional month and paid rent again after that.. IT DO…

1.0★Nov 2024

First I will say this. Do not waste your time or efforts renting with these people. They are GREEDY, UNPROFESSIONAL, IRRESPONSIBLE AND CARELESS. I have lived in a property managed by them for the past 4 years here are the things that I dealt with while they were in charge of the property. 1.) VERY VERY RARE COMMUNICATION - you can call them 20 times and ask for your property manager to call you back, leave messages after messages and they will not call you back for months. Show up at the actual office and NOBODY IS THERE EVER. I had to call the office in Pensacola 99% of the time to get a res…

5.0★Nov 2023

Palm Island Realty Property Management has been great to rent our house from this far. They have one of the best with Crystal. She showed me the place first with a thorough walk through.Then she took time out to show my husband and I together on a completely different day. She was very effective with her communication! She made sure we would get into this place smoothly without any issues. From the application process to getting the keys, it was a smooth process. Maintenance requests have been fulfilled in a timely manner. And even a key lock out was handled quickly and in my opinion with care…