Vintage Real Estate Services Reviews

I've been using Dave Sigler's Vintage Real Estate Services to manage my Riverview rental Townhouse for ten highly satisfied years now. I want to express how easy he and his people make everything. My wife saved up some money and we decided to invest in more Real Estate, instead of the stock market, in large part because of how easy Dave and his people make it. We've added a second rental now. When something needs fixing they get on it immediately and get it fixed. For bigger repairs, they get me quotes, which I have cross-shopped and could not beat. They get great tenants too. I've had no prob…

I’ve been with this company with a little over a year, poor communication a lot of hidden fees. My home was on market for almost two months before they were able to locate a tenant. I have to constantly email property manager Amber H to tell all the hidden fees that I will be charged for, simply I don’t like the lack of break down. My tenant submitted a ticket for a leaking faucet. I never approved a vender nor was I informed of which company would be send to my property. But I did receive a bill from a vender who I wasn’t aware of. Overall not the best experience

Trisha and her team at Vintage Real Estate do a fantastic job of overseeing and protecting my property (& my interests) as an absentee owner. Trisha is proactive in trying to mitigate any potential cost exposure to me. She's also quick & responsive to the tenants needs. Trisha represents me well when dealing with the (sometimes extremely difficult) HOA that governs the neighborhood of my investment property. I would recommend Trisha to anyone looking for a proactive property management team.

Excellent rental management company! Keeps me informed on what’s happening with the property and addresses any concerns in a timely manner. Would definitely recommend! Trisha is outstanding!!

Amber is amazing! This is my first time ever renting out one of my properties and she has definitely made as easy as possible on me. Any issues that my may tenants have, she is quick to respond to them and to notify me!

I’ve been using Vintage Real Estate Services for almost a year as a first-time landlord, and I’ve been very happy with their property management. I primarily work with Amber, who has been consistently responsive to my questions and always provides helpful advice. While renting out my home has come with many unexpected repairs, Amber has been proactive in helping me find the most cost-effective solutions and has always worked with me to make the process as smooth as possible.

This company has been the BEST. Dave Sigler and Amber Hodo are both professionals and it’s been a pleasure to work with both of them from start to finish managing my rental property. Dave helped solve some major challenges for me with tenants which I greatly appreciate. Communication has been quick and comprehensive. As soon as I hired them I breathed a sigh of relief and they handled everything on my behalf. Highly recommend!

I was extremely pleased with Dave and the Vintage property management team. They exceeded my expectations year after year. Becky and her team of professionals also made the Sale of my home a pleasant experience. I would recommend Vintage for property management or for selling your home.

Ive had a positive experience with Vintage real estate managing my property. They are responsive and handle issues promptly, ensuring that my property is well-maintained and that tenants are satisfied. I'm pleased with their service. I would recommend them to other property owners looking for reliable management.

I am a real estate agent and I have investors in France. They have been using Vintage for years. The service they provide is excellent! Especially Trisha, she's efficient, professional and kind!

I'm very happy with the staff at vintage Real Estate thank you Trisha Fulan for being so caring and understanding

If I could give Vintage Real Estate zero stars, I would. READ BEFORE YOU RENT Their rental property on Clark Street is a nightmare. My experience began with what I consider false advertising. The property was advertised as having an in-unit washer and dryer. While a washer and dryer were technically assigned to my unit, they were not located inside my apartment or even inside my building. Instead, I had to go outside and across an aisle to access the washer. Even worse, when I moved in, there was no washer at all despite my lease stating one would be provided. ** I waited nearly two months be…

My family has been screwed over time and time again by this company. All of our maintenance requests were left unanswered and we had to live without AC, leaks from the toilet, a nonworking refrigerator, and our microwave broke. We had mold in the dishwasher. They don’t care about keeping the places that they rent up-to-date and making sure that basic human comfort is essential. Then when we moved out, they basically are keeping our entire security deposit even charging us for things like a toilet paper holder. How do these people sleep at night? They are absolute theives. Everything you’ve eve…

Don't rent out 4611 N Hubert Ave roach invested. They also have hidden fees. Never answers or responds back in a timely matter.

Townhouse $1700/month but all extra UNETHICAL fees we sent a letter for attorney general office and all other government offices. Florida housing crashing slowly Floridians choosing to move out because of this kind of 3rd party brokers OVER pricing illegally Income stays level no raise from employers but this Greedy act like Realpage they will get sued Dear Florida Boycott this office ASAP spread the word on social media Recurring Fees$49.95 - Benefit Package (Mandatory)One-Time Fees$95 - Application Fee (Mandatory), $125 - Lease Processing Fee (Mandatory), $2,100 - Security Deposit (Mandatory…

Trisha has been a great property manager. She has taken care all of our needs, especially with repairs and now lease extensions as we prepare to move out. We really appreciate all she does to make our lives easier.

Maintenance services were very good and efficient. Service worker was very kind, respectful, and helpful and we appreciated their work. They responded to our request quickly and explained everything that was done regarding fixing the issues. I will say, i've had to have maintenance scheduled many more times than i would like within only 3 months of living here, and i actually have multiple other issues that need fixing that I have not scheduled yet because I have already had to have maintenance over so many times at this point. It is also frustrating that it forces you to choose five available…

HVAC Technicians were friendly and repaired the air conditioner within an hour of arrival. We are happy with the results.

The guy that came to my home to redo my bathroom floors did an amazing job. The first day he came. He stayed late to try to get everything done, but he came back the next day to finish the job and I love it. I give this company a five Star

After a confusing and frustrating process, Trisha and Ashley assisted my wife and I in finding a home that better suits our needs. They walked us through the process of the deposits and were very helpful and understanding.

We enjoy living in this complex (Vintage Real Estate) and going to continue to live here.

I am currently at the hospital with my new born baby. I haven't had a chance to leave my wife and newborn to deposit a check to pay rent. I asked for a little understanding and I wasn't even worth a response. I understand I signed a lease and you can easily hide behind that but you didn't even bother to do that. No response to my email. Nataliaa and Trish two of the property managers lack empathy and couldn't be bothered to respond. Like most people and businesses today they just don't care. I wish you both a truly happy holidays. Oh its December, my mailbox still isn't secure from my move i…

In fixing some wear and tear on cabinets at move-in, Deybin was quick, cheerful, and knowledgeable. He also made speedy repairs to the broken sprinkler pipe. Well done!

Trisha was wonderful to work with. Always very helpful and proactive. I would rent with this PM again, without a doubt.

I have had the pleasure of dealing with Trisha F. She has consistently demonstrated professionalism and attentiveness. She is always responsive and willing to assist with any concerns or requests. Her dedication and commitment to excellent service are truly appreciated. Thank you Trisha!

The Vintage team has always been helpful and reliable for us. And we always appreciate Trish's quick action and assistance. Thank you all for looking after our property and for your great service.

The guys came over the same day and fixed my ac immediately! They were very nice and respectful

I would like to say thank you to Trisha Furlan for all her hard work in getting everything set and ready for me to move in, I realize it was time consuming and tedious, but she did it. I'm so grateful, she is a great asset to your company and very dedicated. Thank again Trisha!

I would run from this property management and landlord. I went above and beyond with cleaning even leaving behind a $500 pool vacuum and yet I get charged an additional month of rent which was my security deposit and the reasoning was cobwebs that were apparently not swept in a corner and grass that was never even there when I rented. I would never ever do business with this management company ever again!! Also getting charged for lightbulbs that need to be replaced and touchup paint that was apparently totaling $2000. Absolutely criminal

DO NOT RENT FROM THEM! We had so so so many issues while living there and then they send us a phony bill saying we owe them $700 for things we never had in the apartment. Roaches, ants, termites, nothing is updated. We put 2k down, these people are scam artist slumlords. Our ac didn’t work for 3 months in the summer. We had the apartment flooded from the one upstairs & they had us live in decal matter for TWO months before offering to cut us to find a new apartment but keeping our whole security deposit & then some.

To Vintage Real Estate and Trisha my move out was easy to do. They did a great job with my move out. Thank you everyone.

Would definitely look somewhere else to rent we had issues the entire time we were there.. from catching the homeowner snooping around the yard then denying to vintage about being there. or the fence in the back yard blown down for over 4 months and then blaming the neighbors but still charging full price. Amber in the Brandon office is a nightmare to work with very unprofessional. You turn in work request and they say it’s complete and cancel them definitely look somewhere else.

Christina Whitman helped me with the application process and getting into my new rental home. She was a delight to deal with! She is very nice and responds in a timely manner. I would definitely recommend going through Vintage Real Estate Services for your rental needs! 🤗

Love theme Amazing company, very attentive to every detail and with excellent customer service. Don’t hesitate to rent from them—you won’t regret it!”

Removal and installation of a built in microwave is not an easy task. Your two technicians did it superbly and were very kind throughout the process. Well done!

I miss Vintage as my landlord. I lived at their Madeira Beach property which was destroyed by the hurricane. Let me tell you, I didn't realize how good I had it at Vintage until I was forced to live somewhere else. I never had bugs. If I occasionally saw one, they got pest control out. If something broke, they fixed it. My property manager John Hatcherien was always a pleasure to work with. He would offer to drive 40 miles from Brandon to Madeira Beach to fix something himself. He was always a gentleman. He wrote me a letter I needed for FEMA relief long after my tenancy was terminated, despit…

Me gustaría contar mi experiencia para que otros no pasen lo que yo pase.yo rente una propiedad con ellos y fueron súper amables en todo el proceso,tuve que dar 2000 dólares de depósito y al entregar la propiedad ellos dijeron que esta tenía daños que no fueron hechos por mí sino que ya estaban al mudarme ,ellos tenía las pruebas de que ya estos daños estaban, al igual que yo porque se le tomó foto a todo y ambos las teníamos y aún así me pusieron un reclamo contra el depósito.Dicho esto tengan mucho cuidado a la hora de rentar con ellos porque aunque entreguen la propiedad en óptimas condicio…

always helpful and quick

We had a late night need! The Communication was prompt and the morning follow up was great! We got the service and issue fixed fast, and efficiently! Thanks from the Beynon’s. Under our 2 years with Vintage, we had great experiences with very helpful communication throughout our stay!

Very unprofessional business. Called my wife and then hung up because they got upset. Just another money grab rental company beware! In response to the owners condescending response I would like to update that my wife was not disrespectful and didn't use inappropriate language this just a sad response to cover the truth. We love the area that's why we stayed. But this company and owner are sad and disrespectful people. Also having MOLD covered up in the master with new flooring isn't a proper or legal fix. And we definitely don't want to deal with you directly you are very disrespectful. As yo…

Special shout out to Dave & Trisha, they go above and beyond to make sure everything is correct on their end. Very responsive & respectful, that’s what you need in a property manager! Renting from them these last 2 years has been the best decision we made!

I have never rented from a more efficient property manager. If anything goes wrong they communicate promptly and arrive to fix the problem instantly. Great service, Thank you

Update: Case and point. Owner response 2 months after the initial review was posted. Identifies this as a 1 star review and insinuates I am not real. They have record of me as a tenant, and I was actually generous in giving 2 stars. So even after taking two months to craft a response, they still get all the facts wrong 😂 Original: About what you’d expect out of most companies these days. Poor communication, high turnover, poor service. I went through three “managers” during a 12 month lease. It was like pulling teeth to get any response or cooperation out of them on property issues. Just be c…

Through my lease they fixed anything I needed done very quickly, I absolutely loved the location and property. I have to give a special shoutout to Trisha for being so hard working & dedicated to helping! truly appreciate all that she’s done and how she goes the extra mile! She deserves a big bonus check !

Worst rental experience of my life. I had one bathroom. Clogged toilet, kitchen sink backing up into the bath tub. Property manager would not respond or send a plumber. I had to leave the house for days. Called the office, was told only the property manager could deal with my problem.

Rented through them for a few years.Terrible service. Definitely snakes of people. They like to lie, hang up on you and respond when they want. All the way to even the owner. The staff changes all the time and have no clue what they are doing. Just another money grab company with no care about anything else. Do not do anything through them!

I Lived at a home for 4 years that was managed by vintage. Trisha Furland was extremely professional and helpful.

I would like to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation to Amber, at Vintage Management co. She is professional, responsive and courteous. Thank you helping us, get the home prepared for rental. I am glad you're my rental agent. You are definitely an asset to the Vintage Management team.

I have been thoroughly impressed with the level of professionalism and efficiency demonstrated by its managers. Amber H. Is very professional!

I want to thank Trisha and Vintage real estate for a pleasant experience when renting a property that they managed. Trisha's communication and was responds time very clear and efficient. All my email were responded to same day.I had a couple of things that required replacement and repairs. She had a repair guy there next day each time. I highly recommend Vintage Real Estate 👌.

EXACTLY the same experience as Dominic below. This is a WARNING for ALL those considering to rent via Vintage. DO NOT DO IT. We were tenants for 5 years. Every rent paid on time. Perfect tenants. Top 5% credit score. Upon move out, we get $4,800 (!) worth of repair needs – in a non-itemized flat charge from the other company owner by David Sigler, SouthShore Contracting. Last time I saw such business practices were in a Nigerian port. We challenged immediately and in writing, as per contract. We only get a reply that the deposit is issued to owner nonetheless and we have to pick it up with th…

This was my initial review until end of lease: Excellent service. Prompt and courteous. Always attending to issues right away. UPDATE: Sept. 19, 2025 What a horrible and unfortunate experience regarding the security deposit. Not only was the property left in excellent condition, I have proof that the deducted repairs were related to a past tenant... they then removed those deductions but claimed extraordinary cleaning (totally fabricated). They will not send invoices or breakdown of deduction. I have retained an attorney for further investigation. Stay away from this company they are very d…

Excede atencion, hasta los momentos no he tenido ningun inconveniente… la atencion de marcos es excelente, atento, amable, diligente, gracias por ayudarme con mi primera casita.

Looking for rental property is a very tedious task especially if you don't have prior experience. I was able to speak with Marco after submitting an interest in a property they had available, He was also very kind and answered all my questions as well as letting me know of all the other properties they had available that would fit my family. I especially loved the self tour option we were able to pick a time we liked best to see each home. Marco was very helpful and informative in providing information on the home we wanted and how the whole process would be like which honestly made the whole …

I so love this real estate,the people are awesome and they do are great job when things break they come out fast .you looking to rent come to this place . I'm pleased with this company. 😊

This place is a scam. They are out to get peoples money and the experience was awful. I don't even think half of what they do should be legal. I went to them to rent a house, and the entire time I dealt with a leasing agent named Marco Castro, who was very egotistical, rude, and condescending. My credit wasn't great, and in every conversation he stressed the fact that he was helping me and did not let me forget it. I got approved for one of the properties, and he "forgot" to mention the double security deposit of $3990. When I emailed the actual property manager (whose name was on all of the d…

Gracias…. Muy buenas atenciones ,espero seguir disfrutando de su servicio , tienen un buen trato y mucha paciencia con sus clientes

“Marco was truly one of a kind. His communication skills, innate drive to serve others, and outgoing personality made the whole process nice and smooth. Looking for a new place has never been easier with Marco on my side :)

Expect everything to break, and nothing to be fixed. If it is fixed (rare) it won't be timely - even if it is being without water (16 hours)!!!! Maintenance guy came to caulk the hose on the rear of the house, and didn't use a vice when take off the faucet, and broke the pipe within the wall. Water started dumping into our wall. He shut off water to the house, called vintage, and left. I called vintage, who said they would send someone that night. I waited an hour, called back, and said they were on their way. I called another hour later and only got voicemail the rest of the night. THEY WENT…

love the service Vintage offered, Marco Castro made the process so easy, he communicated everything very clearly, always made sure to answer any questions i had and always called or emailed me back, which is very hard to get these days!!1