First Key Property Management Reviews
First Key Property Management
First Key Property Management, 260 Peachtree St NE, Atlanta, GA 30303
First Key Property Management provides specialized renovation and project-management services for property owners, including punch-out and post-construction cleaning, with an emphasis on renovations for investors, homeowners, and landlords; located in Atlanta, GA, offering professional management services for short-term and long-term rentals.
Landlord vs. tenant ratings
Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.
Photos
Rating breakdown
Based on 11 rated reviews from the last 3 years.
First Key Property Management reviews
Awful experience, super corporate, they'll trample all over your rights as tenants. They'll be nice enough until you sign your lease then deny or weasel their way out of maintenance and every other request. They admitted they didn't clean the house and I found a nail and paint and pills. I've been a renter for over 25 years and never had a worse landlord experience. And they refuse to help or cooperate. This isn't an anonymous review I rent in Houston
I would not rent from them. Communication is horrible and I don’t think that they care about their tenants. I think it’s all about just making money and people pray on the fact that people need living situations renovate your homes better give people decent and livable situations Hire good handyman how do you pay people to do work and they don’t complete it
Horrible deplorable and disgusting company. I hope they get a lawsuit because i would join in immediately. Terrible company never helps resolve issues went without heating and air during a snow storm for a month. Went multiple times without ac only ever got them to actually attempt to fix things if threatened with legal action. They say they work with you with your rent but they dont. The office in my area never is actually open when they said they were. Would never ever rent from them again. Charged us way too much to cut some grass after we had cut it and sent someone out under the guise i…
Worst place I’ve ever over paid to live. This company will rob you blind. Once you sign the lease you’re at the mercy of this company and it’s all about greed. Took me for almost $40k in a year and lived in a home that should be condemned.
ATROCIOUS company. First timer renting a home… only lasted two months before leaving. Worst experience of my life!! I hate this greedy, inconsiderate, heartless company ! Wife almost had a miscarriage tripping and falling on flooring because of their negligence on repairs !!! Hope one day you guys get a class action lawsuit, I’ll be the first one on the list !!
THIS IS ALSO POSTED ON THEIR OTHER GOOGLE PAGES ( I assume they have so many to confuse people) Added Aug 2025 three more pictures of the other side of the wall that originally had mold. When they came out the first time they said they would send a contractor to look and make sure nothing was deeply wrong, but they never did and I never could get them too, and now a year later on the other side of that wall, there is so much water coming from the ceiling That I cannot run my dishwasher and there are multiple soft spots that look like it is about to cave in. Of course, despite that informatio…