AG Rentals Reviews

AG Rentals logo

AG Rentals

4666 W Jefferson Blvd #190, Fort Wayne, IN 46804

4.1 46 verified reviews

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.2 / 5
from 11 owners
Tenant Rating
4.1 / 5
from 35 tenants
High confidence · 11 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo AG Rentals photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
95
4 star
4
3 star
1
2 star
1
1 star
23

Based on 124 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

AG Rentals reviews

5.0★Apr 2026

AG Rentals Property Management has been a great decision for managing my property. What stands out most to me is their quick response time and clear, consistent communication. They make the entire process smooth and stress-free, which gives me confidence that my property is in good hands. I truly appreciate their professionalism and reliability.

5.0★Feb 2026

AG Rentals put up some walls in our basement to create a spare bedroom. They did an incredible job! They answered any questions that we had in a timely manner, they got the job done quickly/efficiently (even with all of this snow and cold) and were super clean. Ed was great to work with. We will definitely reccomend them to others!

5.0★Jan 2026

My family has been renting our house with AG Rentals for over four years. They have always addressed in a timely manner my concerns and repairs when needed. Their team is very courteous, professional and respectful. Thank you AG.

5.0★Nov 2025

Excellent property management company. They found a great tenant within two months, handled improvements to the house and yard to boost appeal, and kept communication clear throughout. Billing is transparent, and the entire process has been smooth and professional. Highly recommend.

2.0★Nov 2025

They have a lot of properties. AG is not easy to work with. I left their services. Most of the properties are bad. They are more expensive than they should be. Maybe this review will help customers and employee's. The owners really need help. Have better standards of yourself. Treat people better.

5.0★Mar 2025

Wow!!!! Most landlords I've experienced were.....awful. Especially in regards to maintenance. I've had nothing but positive interactions and communication with this new company.And the maintenance crew are awewome!!! Very happy!

5.0★Jun 2024

Have managed my properties for years. They are the best in the business. Family owned and family feel. Highly recommend

5.0★Jan 2024

I'm really grateful I was introduced to Sara and Ed at AG Rentals. After having a horrible experience with our last property management company, it is a HUGE breath of fresh air to work with a company that cares about their tenants, is professional, and is thorough with their bookkeeping. I highly recommend AG Rentals as an investor!

1.0★Dec 2023

Though their not too bad at sending their maintenance crew for repairs, They sent Lays Roofing to redo the roof & very short notice meaning a few hours on them starting. I work out of town but headed back asap. Needless to say they did damages to one of my vehicles. Reported it to AG & they blamed me. Very unpleasant & unprofessional experience.

5.0★Dec 2023

I have been totally satisfied with AG Rentals on any maintenance they take care of. Prompt service.We have been renting at our house 10 yrs this coming August - A+ rating

1.0★Oct 2023

Worst experience I ever had as a landlord. f you are a remote landlord and not present locally, avoid Sara and her company like the plague. I had two of my properties under contract with them and had several issues. They quoted me $2500 to refurbish a property which I paid but when I took over the property from them, I found that several of the things were not even done. I had to threat litigation for them to come back and finish those repairs. After doing all those repairs, they were not able to find a tenant for three months. I took over myself with the help of some friends and I was able …