Ardsley Management Corporation Reviews

Ardsley Management Corporation logo

Ardsley Management Corporation

7520 E 88th Pl STE 201, Indianapolis, IN 46256, United States

2.9 17 verified reviews

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
2.8 / 5
from 10 owners
Tenant Rating
3.1 / 5
from 7 tenants
High confidence · 10 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo Ardsley Management Corporation photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
82
4 star
4
3 star
2
2 star
4
1 star
25

Based on 117 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Ardsley Management Corporation reviews

1.0★Jun 2026

HOA/Neighborhood contact Mary Lisa Williams is awful, poor customer service, she ignores communications about neighborhood concerns.

1.0★Jun 2026

Some Rules in the HOA guidelines they "can't" enforce. Others they allegedly enforce, but I don't see everyone making the changes, so seems a little bias, but ok. Idk what we pay HOA fees for, I literally see nothing. Ponds drying up, trash everywhere, playground raggedy, don't plow the roads in winter. I think our neighborhood is still paying HOA because it's just always been that way. Don't bother responding, I don’t want to hear your corporate jargon and blah.

5.0★Jun 2026

Tamara is an amazing property Manager. She goes above and beyond for our community! She is always polite and professional with vendors and all homeowners. We have a few homeowners that do not quite know what is their responsibilty vs the HOA's responsibility and Tamara has been able to navigate these issues and concerns in an expert manner. She always handles issues in a timely manner. She also answers emails promptly and courteously.

1.0★Apr 2026

Kirkwood HOA fees are outrageous and ridiculously high ($693.) We have a non-maintained pond which all of the greenery was sprayed by HOA appointed person. Didn't see a legitimate charge for that. Doggy poop bins installed without 90% of owners input. Half the poop is on the grounds and or bins full for weeks to months. There is a squeaky swing set on small playground. Can hear squeaking a block away. We do not have any amenities. Monies are left over but no clear discussion about where it is being kept or how it should be spent. Heard talk about spending our dues on installation of a fence …

1.0★Nov 2025

This is a terrible HOA. They don’t enforce community rules with any consistency - like the homeowner next to us operating an AirBnB in clear violation of our CCR for months, and despite multiple reports from multiple neighbors, nothing has been done. Emails do not get answered. Phone calls to Cher are never returned, and she never answers her phone. We are considering consulting our own attorney since the HOA has failed to enforce the CCR. Be aware that you will pay fees and get no customer service from this company. Wish DR Horton would change management companies.

1.0★Oct 2025

This is a very poor management company that customer service means nothing. The only thing that matters to them is money. I have lived in the same house for 21 years and instead of being there to protect the customers means absolutely 0 to them. I would recommend going with any other property management company except them. I had 6500 properties at one time in my life and would never ever treat someone like they did to me. I advised my best friend today to pull every property he had with them. As of the end of their contract they will lose all of these properties as well. I travel back and for…

2.0★Aug 2025

I reported animals on my property and reported who was responsible for them and they wrote him 3 letters and still wasn’t anything done and I think they should have taken more action against this issue .If he would not listen to the warning they should had charged him a fee . Not I have to put up with this mess on my property.what is the HOA for other than charging us at the end of the year.Im very disappointed and disgusted with this.

1.0★Nov 2024

I’m disappointed that I had to give this organization at least 1 star to write this review. They are the HOA for the Community where I reside and they are horrible! Their response to inquiries is non existent. I called several times to reach Cher Johnson and Kevin Schwarz. It was my third time calling that I was told they are both too busy to talk to me or to return my call. This is day 4 and I’m still waiting. While my experience with MI Homes was favorable I would warn anyone who is thinking about buying a home in this community to think twice because of their affiliation with Ardsley. When …

5.0★Oct 2024

We have had a great experience working with Yolanda Cardenas for years! She is wonderful and cares for her customers and HOA customers. Together we alwasy make sure the customers are taken care. Great company and great people! I would have them manage my HOA if I could!

5.0★Apr 2024

We would like to commend Ardsley Management for taking excellent care of our neighborhood. They have consistently insured the homeowners properties, landscaping, common areas, pool and streets are well kept. It is a neighborhood we are proud to live in. Ardsley manager, Christopher Short, brings a high standard of communication, attention to detail and knowledge that makes Ardsley Manamgement a company that homeowners trust to ensure their neighborhoods are well kept, safe and beautiful.