CRM Properties Reviews

CRM Properties logo

CRM Properties

4216 N College Ave #6, Indianapolis, IN 46205, United States

4.7 239 verified reviews

CRM Properties specializes in managing rental properties in Central Indiana, specifically in the Indianapolis, Kokomo, and Carmel areas, offering a rental analysis service for owners.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.6 / 5
from 41 owners
Tenant Rating
4.7 / 5
from 198 tenants
High confidence · 41 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo CRM Properties photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
543
4 star
15
3 star
2
2 star
1
1 star
28

Based on 589 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

CRM Properties reviews

5.0★May 2026

I changed Property Management companies early this year after just a debacle with my previous Manager! I literally can't express how impressed I am with CRM Properties! They are proactive, Landlord centric, while understanding that a happy tenant stays, reducing vacancy expense. I should have made the moves years ago!

5.0★Mar 2026

I love work with Heather over the years I was with CRM Property. She works with the tenants on making sure all need are meant, while living in the house.

5.0★Feb 2026

Rodrick knight awesome guy great attitude good work ethic went above and beyond to help with my family’s problem with there rental property

5.0★Dec 2025

Always such a pleasure working w/ Jennelle - she's very responsive and friendly. She took lead on onboarding recently for us, and thankfully, made our lives very simple. Would recommend to anyone

5.0★Dec 2025

My property manager Lilly has been great! She communicates well, chases the details and keeps me informed. She also helps direct me the right way when I'm not sure. I appreciate all she does for me! My agent Audra has been invaluable! I appreciate all the deals and insights she sends my way. I can count on Audra to guide me towards the right deals for me - she has my best interest in mind! I appreciate Lilly and Audra, and the entire CRM team. I highly recommend them to any real estate investor in central Indiana.

5.0★Dec 2025

I work with several property management companies across Central Indiana, and CRM stands out for a very professional operation. Where many prop management companies are mom and pop or family shops, CRM is larger and as a result is able to provide a fuller spectrum of service with dedicated employees. Our property manager, Jessie from the Gold Team has been great to work with, and has taken good care of us with our properties in both Kokomo and Indianapolis. I have also enjoyed working with Katie on the brokerage side. Definitely recommend looking at this company if you are an owner looking for…

5.0★Dec 2025

I cannot describe how awesome and helpful Audra is! She has worked a few deals for me and my team and each one has been a great experience. Very communicative, knowledgeable and professional! The property management team is fantastic also! Very highly recommended!

5.0★Dec 2025

Very helpful to get answers about our property and community - responsive and thorough.

5.0★Nov 2025

This was our first time working with a property management company, and from the very beginning, the experience has been excellent. When I had the initial 30-minute call with Bethan, all my concerns were quickly eased. She took the time to answer each of my questions thoroughly, and my husband and I immediately felt confident that this was the right company for us. What really stands out is their transparency. The fees were exactly as listed on the website—no surprises at all. The onboarding process was clearly explained step by step, which made everything easy to follow. From scheduling the c…

5.0★Nov 2025

Austin with CRM has been very helpful with getting the tenants fixed with any issues that comes along. Austin has great message and call returns when needed. Megan and Emily have been really great to work with on the rehab side of CRM Property's. Lilly and Emely are a big of keeping everything in order with Tenants and vendors. Minerva and David who work Tec support also have a big role of keeping everything in order with CRM...A big shout out with all persons mentioned share a big role in keeping a company running smoothly. Also there are others not mentioned that play there part in this pro…

5.0★Oct 2025

Austin really helped to get someone out to my property quickly. CD was very informative and did excellent job fixing my issue.

5.0★Sep 2025

Lynda is 10/10 on her organization and bill paying abilities!

5.0★Sep 2025

Sad to be leaving this property management company but I have decided to make some life changes and get out of real estate. This is one of the greatest property management companies I have ever worked with. Chris and Julie know their stuff. EVERYONE on the PM team has been very knowledgeable. The 2 leasing girls are just great as well. I was stopping by one of my vacant rentals and happened across Emily writing a scope of work for their make-ready. They had my property rent ready a lot faster than other 'management' companies and at least 60% less expensive. Maintenance was well, maintenance.…

5.0★Jul 2025

We have worked with CRM for a little over a year now and they are always a pleasure to work with and I truly think they do an amazing job with property management compared to many other companies we have worked with. Recently we had a issue with IHA and Heather & Meztli worked continuously with me and IHA until it was resolved which took about 6 months!

5.0★May 2025

We have been with CRM for about two years. What we like best is that all the systems are in place for rental property owners. We know that whatever happens with our properties, it will be taken care of quickly and competently. Our CRM person of contact is Brittany. We can always count on her to be efficient, and a good communicator. She is willing to explain issues simply, and be our advocate as well. We recommend CRM.

5.0★May 2025

Great company to work with. I’m happy and my tenants are happy with their service. Thank you CRM.

1.0★May 2025

There was a “glitch” in their rentvine system and apparently we have to back pay whatever was owed. As a business owner ourselves, if we messed up something we would eat that cost, not pin it on our client! They called themselves out when she said each barcode was specific for each house. So now our barcode we scan is in someone else’s hands? So that’s on THEM! Not us. We recently lost our baby at 16 weeks, so we thought someone was being kind and paying our rent. Silly us i guess! Scum lords!!!!! Stay away!!!!! If they mess up, it’s your fault! OH, but let’s not mention the work tha…

5.0★May 2025

Jennelle was a pleasure to work with! She was truly a great leasing manager as she was able to help us lease our dream property, and break down the whole process so effortlessly.

1.0★May 2025

- 10 stars, If you want to save your money and don’t want to waste your time, please CRM is not a good option. Every month they make charge for "repairs." Until now, we haven't received our full rent. Our house was built in 2021. We moved to another state for work and had to rent it out. In previous years, we took over the property management, and I have to say that during the time we took over, there were no complaints about repairs. This year, we decided to hire CRM because I read good reviews. Absolute disappointment. As I said, they charge for repairs that we don't know if they're real. We…

4.0★May 2025

Emily Booher did a quick and unobtrusive inspection!

5.0★May 2025

Emily B did a great job completing our inspection. She was efficient and very friendly.

5.0★Apr 2025

Emily did a great job with our annual inspection. She came in and explained exactly what she was going to do. She was very professional. The inspection was quick and unobtrusive!

5.0★Apr 2025

She was so nice and fast

5.0★Apr 2025

Had an inspection done by Emily she was very respectful to my belongings while i was not home thank you Emily :)

5.0★Apr 2025

It was a little nerve wracking to have an inspection (even though my house is well kept) but Emily made me feel really comfortable. She’s pretty rad :)

5.0★Apr 2025

Emily did a great job with our annual inspection, didn't even notice anyone was in the house. Thanks!

1.0★Jan 2025

Speaking as a landlord. Horrible experience

5.0★Jan 2025

Emily Booher is great and I am happy she is apart of CRM. Now I know someone who I’m comfortable talking to about my property management. She is very personable and has great customer service.

5.0★Nov 2024

I needed new locks installed at my house. David.A was the maintenance man that showed up. He managed to get all the locks changed while working way past quiting time and he even came up with a brilliant idea on how to install a dead bolt on a door that was actually to thin. He obviously understood how important it was for me to feel safe in my own home and refused to quit until he himself was confident in my saftey. Thank you David for taking the extra time to go above and beyond. I appreciate it more than u know

5.0★Oct 2024

We had a great experience working with Darany Cancino and Megan Belanger while securing a rental property and living out of state. They were both super responsive and helpful during this process. Thank you!

5.0★Sep 2024

CRM Properties recently took over management of my rental property. Heather has done an amazing job keeping me informed about maintenance issues, lease termination and vacancy processes, and providing management statements as required for tax purposes. Heather’s pleasant and efficient manner has been exceptional. Thank you.

5.0★Sep 2024

Heather is amazing! She has been very easy to communicate with, as well as very on top of everything when it came to recommending updates to our property once a lease terminated. She has done research for us and has kept everything moving along quickly. She's the best, thanks Heather!

5.0★May 2024

I've been using CRM for about a year now, and they've been doing a great job. Brittany is assigned to my property and has always been responsive in matters regarding tenants, maintenance, as well as advice and insights on the market. Overall, I highly recommend them!

5.0★Mar 2024

I had a situation where I was not aware of a mandatory Section 8 inspection until the last minute due to factors outside of CRM's control. Once notified of the urgent situation, CRM took immediate action to ensure the appropriate repairs were performed and to schedule the re-inspection. They kept me updated during the entire process. Not only did CRM finish the repairs well in advance of the re-inspection, they were also significantly under budget. A sincere thank you and special recognition to Heather Johnson and the CRM Blue Team for their incredible work and professionalism!

5.0★Mar 2024

CD was very nice, detailed and professional when coming into my home 👌 thank you for great service 😀 👍

5.0★Mar 2024

CRR Properties and especially Brittany are the best we have ever worked with. She is prompt and very informative. Helping us stay on top of investment and making sure that we everything goes smoothly I can recommend Brittany and the whole team as a go to management company. It is a pleasure doing business with CRM Property Management

5.0★Mar 2024

Our property account managers, Ashlea and Brittney, are good at keeping us informed and updated about our properties. This takes some of the stress out of rental ownership. The in-house repair folks seem to be pretty knowledgeable too. Thanks CRM.

5.0★Mar 2024

I've been utilizing CRM led by Brittany and her team, to oversee my rental properties, and I couldn't be more pleased with their service. Brittany and her team are exceptionally helpful and remarkably communicative. They have consistently demonstrated a high level of professionalism and dedication to ensuring that my property is well-managed. One of the standout qualities of CRM is their commitment to open communication. Brittany and her team are always readily available to address any concerns or questions I may have, and they keep me informed about any developments regarding my property in …

5.0★Feb 2024

I am a new investor with CRM and so far the process has been great. Audra is my realtor and has done a spectacular job helping me navigate the Real Estate Space in Indy. Rachael Nichols has been my onboarding manager and really did a great job in getting my input into the system. Brittany is my property manager and has been able to be flexible with my rehab and management needs. Thanks all, looking forward to a great relationship and portfolio growth!

1.0★Dec 2023

Deeply unhappy. Hidden surcharges, tricky verbiage in their contract and disburse funds a month in arrears without disclosure before signing of their contract. They do not advocate for their owners. I’d advise to seek other management

5.0★Oct 2023

I have a property in Bloomington and I called CRM and Grace answered right away. They don’t manage in that area but now I know who to call if I acquire more properties in Indianapolis. Thanks Grace