Dorfman Property Management Reviews
Dorfman Property Management
827 N Capitol Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Dorfman Property Management specializes in managing rental properties in the Indianapolis area, including all townships and surrounding communities, and offers an owner portal for easy access to property management information.
Landlord vs. tenant ratings
Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.
Photos
Rating breakdown
Based on 25 rated reviews from the last 3 years.
Dorfman Property Management reviews
DONT RENT from DORFMAN!! My husband and I rented with Dorfman for 5 years. We decided to move out of state and requested our payment history for a new rental and they said no and did not give any reason why. After calling the office and leaving messages with everyone I could and still no response. Another time, our AC was showing an error code and we called maintenance to fix it. The repair man said that we needed to use cheaper air filters, even though I have allergies. We were then charged $350 out of pocket.
We have been tenants with Dorfman for the past 6 years and our experience has been the absolute best! Maintenance issues are always resolved in a timely manner. Responses to emails are always timely as well. They have worked with us during hard times and for that I am very grateful especially in today’s world! Lisa, Rhonda and Andrew are always a pleasure to speak with. I highly recommend using this company to find your new home! -Eboni
1* because Google doesn't let you choose zero. These people will not inspect the property prior to you signing, but hold you to the letter of the lease and charge you for things they left out of place from before you took over. While you live there, they will decide when they want to come inspect the property and take photos of your shit and if you don't follow their rules about that to the letter and decide not to inspect, they'll charge you $100 to reschedule their "15 minutes tops" inspection. They did get our heat turned back on when the furnace died- but I suspect that was entirely the pr…
I have called Drew and Rhonda 4 times left voicemails and emails and have gotten nothing bad. This is a very urgent phone call which I told them my situation and they still can't pick up the phone and call me back.
They're quick and efficient and the property is real nice I love my new house. I look forward to living here a long time. My little dog loves having a front porch. It's nice to have a house for Halloween so I've already started decorating.
These people are horrible and racist I will never rent through this company again no were not mad we already planned on not signing another lease and we are still here we been dealing with a racist neighbor and she has been calling our rental office making lies got our car towed called us niggers they tell us well lisa tell us we breached our lease I've left message emailed them and texted no response but this neighbor has been able to get in contact with them for some reason I think they know each other so we are getting harrassed but we gotta go if that's not racist idk what it is and not t…
I have rented from several companies in the past couple of years and they all have been greedy corporations who have no regard for their tenants. However, these past few years, I rented from dorfman and they always responded back to me when needed. I just recently moved out and honestly didn't leave the place in the best condition. They fixed everything and sent me back a check with a itemized receipt of what they fixed and gave me a check with the rest of my security deposit without me even asking. I know that should be what every company should do, but it's hard to come by nowadays. If i eve…
I've been renting from Dorfman Properties for almost 5 years. I've had a great experience with repairs that need to be done, great communication and everyone always seems to care and want to help me in anyway they can. Would definitely recommend them to anyone looking to rent..
Since zero stars are not an option, DO NOT USE DORFMAN! Rhonda and Drew are disrespectful, and rude. There is no maintenance available ever! Please save yourself the stress and anxiety of trying to pay your rent to slumlords. They wouldn't even open the door when I went to the office.
I would strongly recommend not renting when Dorfman is involved. Non responsive, rude….charges a monthly management fee and renter resolves all issues.
PROPERTY OWNERS BEWARE!!!!!! This review is coming from a current and NEVER AGAIN Tenant. I’ve FINALLY MOVED. Before you use this company services….. Look at one of the picture I’m attaching to confirm my experiences, dissatisfactions and decision to NEVER EVER USE this company as anything more than a LAXATIVE. DORFMAN IS A HORRIBLE COMPANY with RIDICULOUSLY SMART MOUTHED AND RUDE EMPLOYEES. With an extremely high turnover rate of tenants No home owners should want to use this company. You will have a lot of people moving in and out. They charged me $175 for blinds that I put in. They didn’t i…
PROPERTY OWNERS BEWARE!!!!!! This review is coming from a current and NEVER AGAIN Tenant. I’m CURRENTLY MOVING RIGHT NOW. Before you use this company services…. Please check back here for my review in a few days. I’ll be also posting some screenshots of emails and text messages to confirm my experiences, dissatisfactions and decision to NEVER EVER USE this company as anything more than a LAXATIVE.
Absolutely not very rude and disrespectful when I was signing my lease they asked for my deposit in cash that should have been ared flag for me they were so nice while I was signing after that it went straight down hill they even told me I wasn't allowed to have company my house caught on fire twice due to electrical issues instead of hiring a professional they sent out a 90 yr old man who could barely see Rhonda is the ring leader she will literally cuss you out and threaten to kick you out if you try to speak up for yourself please take all the reviews seriously and don't rent from them I wi…