Golden Sky Management Reviews

Golden Sky Management logo

Golden Sky Management

3121 S Walnut St, Muncie, IN 47302

4.5 97 verified reviews

Golden Sky Management offers full-service property management with in-house maintenance in Muncie, Anderson, New Castle, and Indianapolis, providing a transparent fee structure and an owner portal for financial reporting and inspection documents. They have over 8 years of experience managing properties across 8 counties in Central Indiana.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
3.7 / 5
from 9 owners
Tenant Rating
4.6 / 5
from 88 tenants
High confidence · 9 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Rating breakdown

5 star
111
4 star
16
3 star
4
2 star
2
1 star
14

Based on 147 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Golden Sky Management reviews

5.0★Nov 2025

I have had this company manage a home for a few years now. They are just awesome! It has been easy and worry free. They have always been super professional and have done a great job. Highly recommend them.

3.0★Oct 2025

They just took over my property my experience has been good so far. They showed up for my matience request when said. They actually update things when not done right.

1.0★Jun 2025

My son and his mom from these people very nice the place was nice. They lived there for a few months never any issues.... His mom got engaged and moved to Texas. They followed the whole process according to Sarah they even paid their rent with nobody living there until somebody new signed the lease! The apartment was left immaculate needing absolutely nothing the reason for the one star is because they were promised to deposit in return..they followed all the rules for departure every instruction that was given to them they did exactly what they were told to do in order to receive their depos…

5.0★Feb 2025

They took over my property as my old landlord sold it and so far they’ve been pretty great!

5.0★Nov 2024

Our building has only been under their management for a few months, but so far they've done a really good job with communication and following up on any issues that arise. And they've been amazing to work with!

1.0★Jul 2024

I had this so called property Management company under an agreement to manage my newly purchased rental homes. While I had 3 of 6 apartments under renovation, GSM terminated my service agreement due to " unhabital" apartments unit. They only want to manage properties with minimum effort. GSM did not take care of a tenant issue nor communicated to me that a tenant had an issue. GSM, and especially Joann lacks in communication overall. In the same termination email they even offert to reinstate the service when the apartments are completed. I think I am going to pass on that!

4.0★Dec 2023

Golden sky recently bought our property. So far they have been great.

1.0★Nov 2023

As an owner - use any other company or do it yourself. They took 6 months to rent one of our properties we onboarded, and tried to charge us close to $3000 in repairs they deemed "necessary", which we had our contractor complete for around $600. They don't have any maintenance of their own for any large repairs, and charge markups on all vendor coordination. So jobs that should be around $800 are getting billed out upwards of $1400. Communication is nonexistent, and they take no accountability for places not being rented. To top that off they don't do all the tours themselves, they put keyboxe…

5.0★Oct 2023

Our experience with Golden Sky Management following the acquisition of a multi-family complex in Muncie, Indiana, was exceptional. Their team's professionalism, efficiency, and expertise made the onboarding process remarkably smooth. Golden Sky Management's tailored approach to our specific needs, transparent communication, and commitment to excellence have built a strong foundation for an ongoing partnership. We highly recommend them for anyone seeking a property management company that delivers a seamless onboarding experience and trustworthy support.