Progress Residential Reviews

Progress Residential logo

Progress Residential

5720 W 71st St, Indianapolis, IN 46278

3.8 155 verified reviews

Progress Residential specializes in managing single-family homes and townhomes in the Indianapolis metro area, offering a streamlined digital experience for self-tours, applications, and home management.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
3.5 / 5
from 8 owners
Tenant Rating
3.8 / 5
from 147 tenants
High confidence · 8 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo Progress Residential photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
159
4 star
6
3 star
1
2 star
5
1 star
54

Based on 225 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Progress Residential reviews

1.0★Apr 2026

This property is at 6860 West Stansbury Boulevard in McCordsville Indiana this company refuses to take care of this house we talked to the people that lived in it before and they were forced to move out because of mold in the house making their children sick not to mention all the rotting wood on the exterior of the property the grass not being cut or maintained to the HOA standard the garage door that's been ran into and not repaired this is dropping property values in the neighborhood this company owns several homes in the neighborhood and all of them look bad stay away from this company

5.0★Feb 2026

Progress directly, was essentially zero help! My regional reps for my address on the other hand have been nothing short of EXCEPTIONAL ! Calvin and Rhonda have been there every step of the way to answer any and all questions! I am no longer utilizing progress customer service, instead I turn to these 2 angels as my first point of contact!

5.0★Feb 2026

This company is amazing. Mark is great at his Job, he addresses any concerns I have, and my house is lovely with beautiful appliances. Rent from Progress! Thank you Mark!

5.0★Jan 2026

Mo is the best tenant representative I’ve worked with at this company. I’ve been with Progress for over 5 years and he has gone above and beyond for my family since he’s started working for the company. The best customer service and always willing to help. Thank you for all you do for the company is appreciated!

1.0★Aug 2025

The service team who schedules maintenance request is terrible. I’ve had an issue with my fence about to fall over since June 2025. They had 2 different vendors come out and “fix” the issue and I have had 2 2x4 boards replaced. Then they send a tech from progress come out to look at the issue and all that was done was a gate latch replaced.

1.0★Aug 2025

To many problems to really list here, but multiple times I have been overcharged a d had my payments "lost". I am to the point where I am considering legal action and of course no one at progress cares they just continue to charge me cause they think they can get away with stealing from people.

5.0★Jul 2025

I had Lynn as my maintenance guy he fixed the problem at my home I definitely will recommend again he wasn’t supposed to be here between 1-5 pm he came an hour early and it took only 15 minutes and the job was fixed thank you

1.0★May 2025

A storm came through two weeks ago I reported a tree down in my yard I’ve called multiple times to get an update they told me I can call the company myself to get an update so today come 5/29 and the tree was supposed to be removed and progress required me to be home or I would need to pay a $75 fee I stayed home missed work to avoid the fee and nobody ever showed up to remove the tree my grass is extremely high and I can’t get it cut because a tree is down in my yard that has been there for weeks this is unacceptable and nobody is any help the people you call and talk to never know what’s goi…