SHIELD Property Management Reviews

SHIELD Property Management logo

SHIELD Property Management

8800 North St #111, Fishers, IN 46038

4.5 10 verified reviews

SHIELD Property Management specializes in residential property management in Hamilton County, Indiana, offering tailored programs designed to meet the unique needs of property owners.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.6 / 5
from 7 owners
Tenant Rating
4.3 / 5
from 3 tenants
Medium confidence · 7 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

SHIELD Property Management photo SHIELD Property Management photo SHIELD Property Management photo SHIELD Property Management photo SHIELD Property Management photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
19
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
1

Based on 20 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

SHIELD Property Management reviews

5.0★Mar 2026

I cannot say enough great things about Matt D’Angelo and the team at Shield Property Management. From start to finish, they have been absolutely outstanding. Matt is incredibly professional, responsive, and genuinely cares about both the property and the people involved. Every interaction has been smooth, transparent, and efficient. He goes above and beyond to ensure everything is handled quickly and correctly, which is such a rare find. You can truly tell he takes pride in his work and values building strong, trustworthy relationships. Shield Property Management as a whole operates at a very…

5.0★Feb 2026

I highly recommend working with SHIELD property management, Matt D’Angelo in particular! He bring a high level of professionalism, timeliness, and customer service that is unmatched. I can’t say enough great things about Matt & SHIELD Property Management.!

5.0★Jan 2025

I was looking for honesty, professionalism, and peace of mind. Simply put, I didn’t want to ‘deal’ with managing all that goes into having a tenant/property. SHIELD has definitely provided that ease and convenience to being a rental owner. Matt is very communicative and has a great feel for finding solutions. I can’t recommend Matt and his team highly enough.

5.0★May 2024

"Shield Property Management has been an invaluable partner in managing my investment properties for several years now. Their dedication to exceptional service and proactive communication is truly outstanding. They handle tenant concerns promptly, ensure maintenance issues are swiftly resolved, and provide comprehensive financial statements that make it easy for me! I highly recommend Shield Property Management to any property owner seeking peace of mind and professional expertise."

5.0★May 2024

It's very difficult to find a good property management company. Over the years, my wife and I have acquired a mixed bag of properties in a few different states. I literally dread seeing an email from our other management companies in my inbox, and it's worse if I see them calling. When Matt calls from Shield, it's literally like family is calling! If there is any issue, he already has it solved, or he has my options all laid out for me. He's upbeat and efficient, and I know things are in good hands. They also go above and beyond to manage any cost! Shield is also a true win / win because t…

5.0★Dec 2023

Easy to work with. Conscientious, energetic AND identified a great tenant very quickly. Will definitely re-use.

5.0★Oct 2023

Glad to have Shield managing my investment property!