Guardian Property Management Reviews

Guardian Property Management logo

Guardian Property Management

1402 E Mishawaka Ave, South Bend, IN 46615

4.7 149 verified reviews

Guardian Property Management specializes in scattered-site property management, serving approximately 250 residential real estate investors and managing over 1,100 housing units, with a focus on single-family homes, townhomes, condos, and multi-unit buildings.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.5 / 5
from 19 owners
Tenant Rating
4.7 / 5
from 130 tenants
High confidence · 19 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

Guardian Property Management photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
304
4 star
5
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
11

Based on 320 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Guardian Property Management reviews

5.0★Apr 2026

Donna was very helpful in getting documents I needed for the tax year !

5.0★Apr 2026

Guardian has been on top of all of our maintenance, has kept our property clean & well organised. Thankful to have a good management company for once

1.0★Jan 2026

Guardian has been appointed by inspector Dan LaQuax of Minneapolis to do some repairs and am now receiving information that the repairs are around $100,000 with no explanation or itemization of what work is being done!!! Started with replacing a boiler….

5.0★Aug 2025

I want to give a shout out to our property manager, Kelly and Guardian. They are incredibly responsive and takes great care of the property and tenants. Kelly goes above and beyond!

5.0★Jul 2025

Guardian Property Management have been great to work with in taking care of our two rental properties. They have been very responsive to our needs and have saved us much time and energy in dealing with tenants and repairs etc… I would highly recommend them.

4.0★May 2025

Guardian Property Management has been a reliable and professional presence in managing our salon building. They’re responsive to maintenance needs, keep the property well-maintained, and communicate clearly when updates or changes arise. It’s been a smooth and positive experience working with them—definitely appreciate their consistency and care.Ps. Kelly rules 🙌🏾

5.0★May 2025

As a new rental property owner, GPM was a fantastic partner to help us get up and running smoothly! The entire team is incredibly helpful and eager to ensure the tenants and owners are happy. Communication with the GPM team is always quick, thorough, and helpful. If you're looking for a great partner for your properties, reach out to GPM!

5.0★May 2025

I have been consistently impressed with Kelly’s dedication and professionalism in managing our building. She goes above and beyond her standard responsibilities to ensure the property remains well-maintained and clean, surpassing the efforts of previous management companies. Most notably, Kelly is proactive in addressing issues promptly and effectively. Throughout our interactions, she has always responded promptly and thoroughly, even when immediate solutions were not readily available from the ownership. Every conversation ends with her being recognized as an exceptional problem-solver and …

5.0★Mar 2025

They manage one property for me but they treat me like I am a very important customer which is awesome.

5.0★Feb 2025

A couple years ago I had Guardian Property Management manage my home I owned and was very happy with their service. Fast forward to today, I am now on the renting side and love it! Guardian is quick with responding and super informative when explaining what needs to be turned in and signed. The online renter portal is user friendly and makes it super easy to pay rent. My favorite is the fact that I can text Guardian Property Management because who wants to open up their email every time they have a question? not me!! If you're looking to rent, rent with them!

5.0★Feb 2025

Guardian Property Management is a great company to with with. Our property manager Kelly is fantastic.

5.0★Jan 2025

This is a long pending review. We moved out of MN in June last year and chose Guardian property management for managing our property. They have a very efficient team who are super helpful on every stage of the process ( documentation, making the home rent ready, advertisement, online portal for management etc). I'm totally impressed with their team and we can be at peace knowing that the house management is in good hands. Keep up the good work😊

5.0★Dec 2024

We chose Guardian to manage our property and it has been a fantastic experience. Great communication, easy online portal to track all activity and balances. They've don'e everything they said they would do.

5.0★Sep 2024

Guardian has managed my rental properties for several years, and their maintenance services, customer service and follow up are incredible. They are super responsive to any questions or issues that come up and I have used their contracting division several times for larger projects that need to get done on the properties. Their employees are knowledgeable, responsive and experts in their fields.

5.0★May 2024

My property manager on Grand ave, Kelly is amazing! Always goes above and beyond for anything we need! She is greatly appreciated!

5.0★May 2024

Kimberly and all the staff at Guardian are so wonderful to work with, they are very receptive and really have provided peace of mind. Thank you Guardian!

5.0★Apr 2024

I am a landlord and have been a client of Guardian Property for almost 10 years. Their service has always been exemplary and their employees friendly and helpful. As an example, to single one out in particular, is Service Tech Dave Olson. He treats my properties like they were his own and always makes the extra effort to see that jobs get done right. I am grateful for their efforts in the pursuit of excellent property management.

5.0★Feb 2024

We have worked with Guardian for many years now and love them. Theyre always friendly and easy to work with. Nycole has especially been our point person. She solves problems on the fly, gets things done rapidly and streamlines our process. Very thankful for the entire team also. Hope to keep working with Guardian for many more years!

5.0★Jan 2024

They have been the property managers for 7 years can’t say enough good things about them! They are highly attentive and care like they live here! Dave is always on time and does a thorough job!