Proper Stays Reviews

Proper Stays logo

Proper Stays

Proper Stays, 10990 E South Ave, Walkerton, IN 46574

4.6 9 verified reviews

Proper Stays specializes in managing short-term vacation rentals at Koontz Lake, offering a unique lakefront experience with amenities for large groups.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
Not yet rated
Tenant Rating
4.6 / 5
from 9 tenants
Not yet rated by landlords

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo Proper Stays photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
12
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
0

Based on 12 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Proper Stays reviews

5.0★May 2026

This beautiful home was the perfect setting for our ladies' family weekend, offering every accommodation we could dream of. With enough sleeping arrangements for all 18 of us, it was both comfortable and convenient. The layout is very well-designed, with plenty of bathrooms and showers to accommodate a large group. The commercial ice maker was a fantastic touch, ensuring we never ran out of ice, and there was ample parking for everyone. Additionally, the multiple refrigerators were great for storing all our food for the weekend. Highly recommended for a large family getaway! We will definitely…

5.0★Nov 2025

I had a wonderful stay! The location is perfect, with plenty of restaurants and shops nearby.

5.0★Oct 2025

A perfect place for a large group. It is spacious with so much to do for the kids. Very well equipped kitchen and home. We didn’t need a thing. The management team was top notch with stellar communication. We will stay here again if possible.

5.0★Sep 2025

Fantastic!!! It was super clean…it had everything we could have dreamed about. Hugh kitchen…pantry…coffee bar…pool table…bar…fire pit…hot tub. The list goes on and on. Stay here you will not be disappointed!!! See below a few pics. Sorry I didn’t want to include any with my family on them. We hired a bus to take us to the Notre Dame game. 45 minute commute.

5.0★Sep 2025

Our Family wanted to celebrate our 50th anniversary together. My youngest daughter asked where we wanted to go. I said by water, large enough for all of us, where we can enjoy our time together. Everything was above our expectations! Everyone had a wonderful time. So much fun right there together, on the water, in the water, inside and out. We could not have asked for a better place to celebrate. Spaces where we could all gather. Areas where we had quiet time, amazing views, so much to do together. Thank you for helping to make our 50th Celebration unforgettable. Melody and Bob

5.0★Sep 2025

We had an amazing time at the lake house. The pictures were completely accurate and my family loved all the activities the house provided. The property company was very easy to work with, friendly, and clear. We definitely hope to be back next year.

5.0★Sep 2025

My family and I stayed for my parents 50th wedding anniversary. We had everything we could have needed and more. We have a large family and there was plenty or room. No one was ever bored with all the amenities available to us. It was clean and welcoming with an amazing view of the lake. We couldn’t have asked for a better place to celebrate together.

5.0★Aug 2025

Had THE MOST WONDERFUL time staying here. Accommodated our entire family and more. The house is very luxurious for a great price. All showers were fully stocked and the house came with so much more than necessary (toilet paper, garbage cans/bags, utensils and appliances). Plenty of toys/ kayaks/ lily pad for us to use in the lake. The host was quickly responsive and very generous. We will definitely be staying here again! Thank you so so much!

5.0★Aug 2025

What a wonderful place to stay! The house could accommodate our whole family. It was spacious, beautiful, and had plenty of activities for the whole family to do. We were able to create special memories as a family. We even took family photos by the lake and by the waterfall they built and flowers. You couldn’t ask for a better background. The owners were super kind and flexible. I would highly recommend this property to anyone.