Carnegie Management Inc. Reviews

Carnegie Management Inc. logo

Carnegie Management Inc.

Carnegie Management Inc., 545 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11206

3.8 10 verified reviews

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
Not yet rated
Tenant Rating
3.8 / 5
from 10 tenants
Not yet rated by landlords

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Rating breakdown

5 star
9
4 star
0
3 star
1
2 star
0
1 star
5

Based on 15 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Carnegie Management Inc. reviews

1.0★Jun 2026

I’ve moved out of a building that Carnegie Manages and continue to be charged for rent (over 4k) every month. Management has been unresponsive to my multiple emails, calls and voicemails. I wouldn’t recommend living in any buildings that they manage.

1.0★May 2026

This company does its best to steal tenants deposits and has not problem signing false documentation. I paid my rent on time every month and then had to fight these people in court to get my $$$. This was 15 years ago and I bet they haven't changed one bit.I wouldn't trust these folks further than I could throw them.

5.0★Nov 2025

I appreciate the attentiveness of this management company. They do their best to manage unruly neighbors and maintenance issues in a very professional, timely manner.

5.0★Dec 2024

I have had the pleasure of living in 25 Bruckner Boulevard apartment 2I for the past two years, and as we prepare to move due to work commitments, I can honestly say it is with a heavy heart that we are leaving. Throughout our time here, the experience has been exceptional. The management team has always been responsive and proactive, addressing any needs or concerns with remarkable efficiency. Likewise, the maintenance staff has consistently been on top of all necessary upkeep, ensuring that any issues were resolved promptly and thoroughly. After two years of living here, I have no complaints…

5.0★Dec 2024

Lived in one of their buildings for 4+ years no issues easy to work with highly recommend!!

1.0★Jul 2024

Worst management company I’ve ever dealt with. They are so unhelpful & rude. Whenever something is wrong or there is a complaint, they basically just brush me off & say that’s not really their problem. They can take days to help with urgent matters & that’s if they’ll even be helpful at all. The building hallways & common areas on ocean parkway that I live in is boiling hot in the summer & freezing in the winter. They’ve been saying they’re going to fix this for years. I Litteraly break a sweat making it down in the morning. They deactivated my door fob without notifying me because I had a …

5.0★Feb 2024

Wow!!! Where do I start? Well first you must know that I moved to New York a few years ago and during that time I had been searching endlessly for the perfect apartment: private, quiet, newer, accepts pets, secure package room, and has good quality size rooms and full bath. It was a daunting task during a time where prices had tremendously gone up, and for any one apartment there were endless applications. Brokers were hard to stay in touch with due to such high demand and sometimes not the most pleasant or even professional. Then one day, I came across a gem and Daniel Rivera of Carnegie Mana…

5.0★Jan 2024

Great management company - any issues I had were resolved extremely quickly and they were extremely caring to me not only as a tenant, but as a person.

5.0★Dec 2023

Daniel assisted me with my search for a Brooklyn loft and he was amazing!!! I have just signed the lease and could not be happier. Not only was he extremely friendly and helpful, but he made the process as smooth as ever. I can't wait to move into my new home. Thank you so much!

5.0★Nov 2023

Baila is the lease manager for the property and is always helpful, knowledgeable, and insightful. Highly recommend services!