Luxury Fire Island Homes Reviews

I recently hired Sydney Mccoy and Sebastian with Luxury Fire Island Homes to manage my property in Ocean Bay Park. I was extremely impressed with their track record of 5Star reviews and happy renters… Not to mention healthy financial statements. Sydney has extremely high attention to detail which Im sure contributes to her success. I've worked with a lot of real estate agents on the island, and Luxury Fire Island Homes surpasses all of them. I am so excited for an amazing season as I have the best team by my side.

Working with Sydney, Sue, and the team at Luxury Fire Island Homes was an extraordinary experience that exceeded all our expectations. From the moment we engaged their services, it was clear that they were dedicated to providing unparalleled service and achieving outstanding results. Sydney and Sue's expertise and attention to detail transformed our property into a true masterpiece of luxury living on Fire Island. Their respect for both us and our property was evident in every interaction, ensuring that our home was showcased in its best light. Communication was seamless throughout the entire …

I needed to sell my home fast and I wanted to work with someone local. Susan McCoy with Luxury Fire Island Homes ended up getting me 3 cash offers within 5 minutes of calling her office. I was shocked and I accepted on the spot. IT was such a pleasant experience. I didn’t have to worry about cleaning up my house or showings.. And I even got to pick my closing date. I could not recommend with working with this great team more!!

Sydney and Sue from Luxury Fire Island Homes provided exceptional assistance in facilitating the sale of my home in Seaview. Their expertise and commitment to understanding my requirements ensured a seamless transaction. Their tailored approach to real estate management ensured a smooth process from inception to completion.

Susan's mastery of communication is unparalleled - she ensured I was informed at every juncture and readily available for any inquiries. Thanks to Susan's relentless dedication and expertise, my luxury Fire Island property was swiftly sold at a premium. I enthusiastically endorse Susan and Luxury Fire Island Homes. For those seeking a real estate agent who exceeds expectations, Susan is the ultimate choice!

We loved staying with Jeff and Brett in Ocean Bay Park last year! They were incredible hosts who met us right when we arrived and took care of everything. We’re so excited to book with them again for this year’s vacation

Rented from Luxury FI Homes for a week this past summer and it was wonderful! The house was beautiful and comfortable, and the customer service was helpful. Would definitely rent from them again!

Great house, great host!!

The house was Amazing... all the amenities were top notch.. view awesome...convenience of town and resturants and stores Brian Smith of fire island luxury homes was an excellent person of contact when needed.. THANKS AGAIN Tom Hardgrove and Family

The house was great. We had a fantastic time and would definitely book here again in the future. We have worked with Brian for several years now and have not been disappointed in his professionalism and jovial nature.

Brian at Fire Island Homes is my go-to guy for great rentals on Fire Island. He always exceeds expectations and ensures our entire stay is wonderful.

Doug worked extensively to help me select a wonderful summer rental on Fire Island. His friendly, knowledgeable professionalism of the region and homes there made finding a rental an effortless task. Doug will absolutely be my go-to-guy for all my future Fire Island interests.