My Property Man: Brooklyn Property Management Reviews

My Property Man: Brooklyn Property Management logo

My Property Man: Brooklyn Property Management

My Property Man: Brooklyn Property Management, 1036 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11221

4.5 13 verified reviews

My Property Man specializes in managing condominium buildings exclusively in Brooklyn, offering tailored property management solutions and 24/7 portal access.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.6 / 5
from 8 owners
Tenant Rating
4.4 / 5
from 5 tenants
High confidence · 8 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Rating breakdown

5 star
33
4 star
1
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
1

Based on 35 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

My Property Man: Brooklyn Property Management reviews

5.0★Dec 2025

We are a 12 unit building in BedStuy. The building is 10 years old. We were working with another Property Management Company from the inception of the board. We switched to My Property Man and it has been night and day. What I love is that Cem & Semih are operators and owners -- they care about their clients and their business. They are responsive, thoughtful and for the first time in years it feels as though the board can take a back seat because we trust our property management company. If you are reading this review, its likely because you are fed up with your current management comp…

5.0★Apr 2025

Working with MPM has been a great experience. They’re local, which really makes a difference. They actually come by to check on the building and stay on top of what’s going on. That wasn’t the case with our last management company, so the hands-on approach has been a big improvement. They’re responsive, professional, and easy to work with. Overall, it’s been a smooth and reliable experience!!

5.0★Dec 2024

Gotta say the way they handle maintenance and compliance Puts other management companies to shame. if there would be an option for 10 stars I would put that. Thanks Cem, Semhi, and the whole team!!

5.0★Dec 2024

I have dealt with alot of management companies over the years Cem, Semih, have it by far!!!! They streamline to do lists like no one has ever done in my experience, You can sleep calm at night once they take over your building. Best!!!!!

5.0★Oct 2024

They are incredibly responsive and diligent- we feel very lucky to have such great property managers! Everything is always kept in great shape on our property, and they go above and beyond to do a good job.

5.0★Aug 2024

Our HOA has been working with My Property Man for 3+ years and are incredibly happy with their service, attention to detail, and overall experience. Would definitely recommend them!

5.0★Jul 2024

Samson was amazing helping me prepare and list my apartment so quickly! Lifesaver!

5.0★May 2024

Our 19 unit condo made the building management switch to MyPropertyMan in the fall of 2023 and it has been transformational. Not only is the team knowledgable, detailed and efficient, they are super responsive, clear communicators, and quick to bring qualified vendors to the discussion when issues arise and repairs are urgently needed. The MyPropertyMan team has shown that they take their role as building management seriously and it is clear that they actually care. Highly recommended.