ProRealty Property Management Reviews

ProRealty Property Management logo

ProRealty Property Management

ProRealty Property Management, 233 Monitor St, Brooklyn, NY 11222

4.7 25 verified reviews

ProRealty specializes in managing homeowner associations and multifamily buildings in NYC and NJ, offering a comprehensive approach that includes financial transparency and proactive maintenance.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.7 / 5
from 17 owners
Tenant Rating
4.6 / 5
from 8 tenants
High confidence · 17 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Rating breakdown

5 star
104
4 star
1
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
1

Based on 106 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

ProRealty Property Management reviews

5.0★Jun 2026

I've had a great experience working with Ms. Dianne. She manages one of my properties and has always been super esponsive, easy to communicate with, and on top of things. As someone who's worked with her both as a client and professionally, I can say she's reliable and a pleasure to work with. I'd definitely recommend ProRealty Property Management. Keep up the great work!

5.0★Dec 2025

We’ve used ProRealty for building management services for our small 13 unit condominium and they’re far better than our previous two management companies. George, our building manager, has been very responsive and thorough, and has even offered proactive solutions which we love. The owner, David, has also been impressively hands-on when needed. Great service level. Highly recommend.

5.0★Nov 2025

Thank you for stepping in and helping our building get back on track. We’re already seeing a significant difference and are truly grateful for the partnership

5.0★Oct 2025

Working with Pro Realty has been an excellent experience from start to finish. They run a tight, organized operation and communicate clearly on every project. Their professionalism and consistency make coordination effortless something that’s rare in this industry. I’ve collaborated with John Tolosa on multiple properties, and it’s always been a smooth process from quick decision making and clear direction to timely follow ups. Pro Realty’s team truly cares about maintaining their buildings the right way, which aligns perfectly with our own standards for quality and reliability.

5.0★Sep 2025

I recently moved into a building managed by ProRealty. I've mostly been working with George Sablayan on everything, from arranging for my contractors to come in to do some renovation, to arranging for my movers to do the move, to doing a short water shut off so that plumbers could do some work, to answering mundane questions like HOA payments and plumber referrals. The team there, and especially George, have been very responsive and supportive in helping me navigate through all this, especially as a first time condo owner in NYC. Been a joy to work with them and him.

5.0★Sep 2025

James Khalid at Pro Realty is outstanding! He manages our large building with efficiency and professionalism. After bad experiences with previous management companies, we truly wish we had him sooner. He’s excellent at handling residents’ concerns and providing top-notch service. Highly recommend!

5.0★Jul 2025

Thank you for the call this morning. It's ALWAYS great to hear your voice and to connect. Working with ProRealty has been such a rewarding experience. Our building is lucky to have your company as managers for the finances. YOU and ProRealty have made dealing with our building SO much easier! Until we speak again, please be well and take good care.

5.0★Jun 2025

After decades of mis-management in our Condos - ProRealty came as a savior. They do not have any hidden fees or charges which is common across other property management companies. They have a great team of hardworking professionals and they genuinely want to do a good job and build a name for themselves. We are glad we made the switch. We are saving tens of thousands of dollars a year. Thank you James, Chris, Darwin and Bernadette for all the amazing work you do for us. We really appreciate it. 🙏

5.0★May 2025

ProRealty has been a fantastic management company for our building. They're professional, approachable, and always quick to respond. During a recent compliance issue, they handled everything efficiently, coordinating with contractors and using their expertise to bring the building into compliance. It’s reassuring to have a proactive team you can trust managing the property.

5.0★Jan 2025

Attentive, fairly priced, and on the ball. Happy to have hired them and would definitely recommend.

5.0★Nov 2024

All the staff has been great to work with, we also saved lot's of money over our previous management company, with better service.

5.0★Nov 2024

I’m one of the managing partners of a 7 unit building in Williamsburg Brooklyn, and have been using ProRealty Property Management for 7 plus years. They’re very helpful and reliable when it comes to managing your building. I highly recommend them when it comes to building management. The most importantly is they’re very trustworthy and caring. What more can I say? Just do yourself a favor and use them. -Rob W, Bklyn, NY

5.0★Oct 2024

Ann Santos and the ProRealty team really helped us out in an urgent situation with an active issue in our building. Ann was responsive and helpful in urgently resolving the issue.

5.0★Oct 2024

ProRealty is a wonderful partner. Bernadette is extremely responsive and thorough. We hope to continue to work with them in the future.

5.0★Oct 2024

Professional and reliable. We had a previous issue that was never taken care of with our past management company. When Pro Realty took over as the property management they took care of the issue promptly. They have also set us up with a really good superintendent. So far so good, happy with the service.

1.0★Aug 2024

Totally unresponsive to problems- this has happened multiple times. We're actively looking for new management because this team can take days to acknowledge issues that are urgent where the entire building is reaching out and even then it's only because you pester them. If you want responsive management, look elsewhere. Feel free to DM me with questions. Happy to change this review if they decide to respond to our problems but right now we're paying $4k a month to be ignored. We have tickets open from literally a month ago. Unbelievably bad management. Venus is our person - so maybe it’s not e…

5.0★Dec 2023

I am so glad we switch to using ProRealty. They are responsive, communicative, and really pleasant to work with. I feel like we found great partners to help us manage our condo. Shout out to Romeo, Chris, Vince, Bernadette & Darwin!