The Jay Group Reviews

The Jay Group logo

The Jay Group

The Jay Group, 84 Kosciuszko St, Brooklyn, NY 11205

3.2 7 verified reviews

The Jay Group is a Brooklyn-based property management firm targeting property owners for third-party management of residential properties, with a focus on professionalism and transparency; operates a tenant portal and serves Brooklyn, NY area.

Is this your company?
Claim this page for free to update your details, answer reviews, and get landlord requests.
Claim it free

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
Not yet rated
Tenant Rating
3.2 / 5
from 7 tenants
Not yet rated by landlords

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

The Jay Group photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
2
4 star
1
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
5

Based on 8 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

The Jay Group reviews

5.0★Dec 2025

I rent with The Jay Group at 276 Nostrand. The staff is incredibly responsive and fair and transparent with fees. The building condition is excellent - trash is removed timely, the facilities (gym & roof deck) are awesome amenities given the rent amount, and I never worry about a package getting stolen. Highly recommend living in this building and/or renting with The Jay Group.

1.0★Nov 2025

I lived in this building for a while, and although the apartment itself had potential, the overall management experience was consistently frustrating. Maintenance issues were a recurring theme. The refrigerator situation was especially stressful — it took multiple attempts and follow-ups just to get a functioning appliance, and communication throughout the process was unclear and inconsistent. Even simple requests felt like a battle, and I often had to chase down updates instead of receiving proactive communication. Another major issue was how administrative and billing matters were handled.…

1.0★Jul 2025

SOUNDPROOF THE PICKLEBALL COURT AT 99 FLEET PLACE DOWNTOWN BROOKLYN AMD TURN OFF FLOOD LIGHTS AT 9pm latest! Mental Anguish over Pickleball Court Noises and UNNERVING SOUNDS OF RAQUET SMASHING BALL PLAYERS START AS EARLY AS FROM FROM 7am-10pm EVERYDAY!!! ALL DAY EVERYDAY, THIS IS A QUALITY OF LIFE URGENTLY! PLUS THEY LEAVE THE FLOOD LIGHTS ON PIERCING INTO Residential apartments ALL NIGHT LONG!!! This has to stop!!! They have a PICKLEBALL Court BUILDING LOCATED AT DOWNTOWN BROOKKYN at 99 Fleet Place Brooklyn NY 11201 that is disrupting the mental health of the residents and neighbors p…

1.0★Jun 2024

Inconsistent hot water. Have to run water for over 5 mins to get hot.We have been harassed by the building Manager “Moshe Berger” to take down our reviews but obviously we refused. He called us multiple times late at night around 10pm being rude and disrespectful. I reached out for assistance I needed regarding the lease and he refused to help. Jay Group as a whole is unprofessional. The security and cleaning staff on the other hand are all respectful, kind and helpful. But the manager is actually the worst. Also tenants will leave their clothes in the dryer for HOURS or even overnight in the …

1.0★Mar 2024

I've given this company many chances to redeem themselves and after a call in which I was bullied into changing my last review I have to say that there communication is appalling. While living here I dealt with a water issue that lasted several months. Whenever I ran my bath water it came out brown as you'll notice in the attached photos. I emailed the management offices numerous times; they either ignored me or said they would send someone out and didn't. After another issue in which the toilet and water stopped running all together for a week I got so fed up I went down to the office to tal…

4.0★Dec 2023

I have rented jay group apartment in Brooklyn, NY- the management were very supportive and responsive and ensure carried out prompt maintenance work whenever tenants submit a request. The rent amount were comparatively affordable and most importantly management is alway willing to provide support to tenants. Although, I did have a great experience during my tenancy, but I will encourage the management to ensure continuing renovation of their property to maintain a competitive market standard.

5.0★Dec 2023

I rented an apartment from the Jay Group for three years, and they are the best management! Very diligent when it comes to maintenance and any help! They offer fast correspondence and are a pleasure to deal with!