EquityTeam Property Management Reviews

EquityTeam Property Management logo

EquityTeam Property Management

EquityTeam Property Management, 11427 Reed Hartman Hwy, Cincinnati, OH 45241

4.1 58 verified reviews

EquityTeam Property Management specializes in managing single-family homes and multi-family apartments in the Greater Cincinnati area, offering unique guarantees like reduced repair costs and comprehensive tenant protection plans.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
4.1 / 5
from 18 owners
Tenant Rating
4.1 / 5
from 40 tenants
High confidence · 18 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Rating breakdown

5 star
70
4 star
3
3 star
0
2 star
1
1 star
18

Based on 92 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

EquityTeam Property Management reviews

1.0★May 2026

As a property manager, my experience was terrible. We approached the equityteam letting them know we were choosing a provider based on their ability to get us onboarded and listed FAST. While that was done in our sales experience, once a customer we got the opposite. A month+ of the unit sitting there due to their one and only onboarding person being OOO. Understanding people of people going OOO, yes, but 1 singular person being out freezes your entire companies ability to list a new customers unit? We also exercised our 90 day satisfaction guarantee a month ago, and have not received a pen…

5.0★May 2026

I’ve had two properties in the Dayton area that were managed by Equity Team. They were a pleasure to work with. Charity Vann did a great job of managing the properties and was always helpful even when there were tenant issues that needed addressing. I would definitely recommend them if you are looking for property management support. R. Lindgren

5.0★Feb 2026

As a first-time rental property owner, I’ve been through quite a bit. My property was illegally possessed, and the individual stole nearly everything—including the water heater, stove, microwave, and more. It was a pretty crazy situation overall. At first, I had some concerns with the management process, but considering the circumstances, Charity and her team have been excellent to work with. Once everything unfolded, EquityTeam stepped in and took care of it—they handled the eviction process, replaced all the stolen appliances, repaired the damage, and got the house back on the market in a t…

1.0★Dec 2025

My review is from the perspective of an owner, I previously worked with Equity Team management for about 1 year, in that time there were numerous instances where their lack of management cost me significantly, additionally, I do not believe that their in house pricing on maintenance was as competitive as it should be and I found better pricing on various repairs after searching on my own after receiving bids from Equity Team that seemed too high. Additionally, they charged an excessive amount of fees - annual accounting and technology fee, onboarding fee, offboarding fee, numerous inspection f…

5.0★Sep 2025

I’m a newer RE investor in the Cincinnati area and I definitely recommend Equity Team for property management. Shoutout to the whole team and Claudia for keeping me informed and comfortable throughout every aspect of owning rentals!

2.0★Aug 2025

I didnt have a good experience with this company. This is an updated review upon bad communication . Many times I waited what seemed like a 4 day weekend to hear back about important matters. And many times these responses I waited for, were not actually addressing the issues Iquired about. For example "i don't see my finically x here" 4 day wait only to get "it should be in your email . Thanks " to me that reads as ( just send a generic response to have plausable denialbility )followed by another long wait. In my opinion the practices this company uses are not up to par if you are in rush or …

5.0★May 2025

Carissa with ET has transformed a black cloud property into an amazing property in a matter of months! They're responsive, and can manage any problems because they've seen them all!

5.0★Mar 2025

I am incredibly grateful for the exceptional service provided by John Walko from Equity Team. His extensive knowledge has been invaluable. John and his team went above and beyond to share real estate insights and recommendations, ensuring I made informed decisions. Beyond investment advice, John has also provided exceptional property management services. They have been attentive, responsive, and proactive in addressing any issues that have arisen. Their dedication to maintaining the property and ensuring tenant satisfaction has been truly impressive. Thank you, John, for your dedication and …

5.0★Mar 2025

In first vetting property management teams, Equity Team had presented itself head and shoulders above everyone else. John is committed in protecting my investment. He's such a nice guy, and always makes time for me. No regrets at all going with him. Thank you John!

5.0★Feb 2025

We have been working with Equity team for almost three years now and cannot say enough good things about the service and support we receive in a management company. We began renting our first property with no clue on what to do or how to run it and Carissa has been there for us every step of the way. Carissa is PHENOMENAL. We had a few bumps in the road with tenants, and Carissa handled every issue flawlessly. I know for a fact without Carissa some of the issues (legal and insurance claims) would not have been taken care of properly. She is wonderful and so thankful we have her managing our …

5.0★Jan 2025

Been using Equity Team for a couple of years to manage two of my properties. Compared to other companies I've used previously, they are very professional and strive to not only provide the tenant with a great home but also the owners with great tenants. Charity has been my portfolio manager. She responds quickly, is always extremely professional, and can come up with several solutions to any problem that may arise. She is a pleasure to work with.

4.0★Nov 2024

Claudia was a pleasure to work with concerning one of her tenants. She was conveniently available and seemed to care about the wellbeing of her residents. I look forward to working with Claudia in the future.

5.0★Nov 2024

My summary from working with them for 4 months: Working with Equity Team is everything I’d hoped for in a property management company. They’re very communicative, efficient, and FAST at what they do. I originally set a 2 star review because communication stopped during my onboarding process. But mistakes happen and that’s all it was, a mistake. Since then, I’ve had no complaints and recommend them to anyone looking for a high quality PM company. John and his team have been outstanding

5.0★Sep 2024

EquityTeam has managed my property for over a decade. The property has been vacant for less than a month in that time, which is outstanding. They do a great job of managing the tenant relationship while also taking great care of my property. A good property management company is really necessary to drive maximum value from a rental property, and ET is one of the best in the area. I have recommended ET to others with properties to manage, and will do so again in the future.

5.0★Aug 2024

Equity Team has been an outstanding property management company to work with. As an owner, I have been thoroughly impressed by their professionalism and responsiveness. John, my dedicated point of contact, is incredibly knowledgeable about my property and ensures I'm always informed about everything I need to know. Before switching to Equity Team, I was with another property management company where I constantly felt like just another number. I was often redirected to a general help line and had to re-explain my situation each time I called. During a particularly stressful eviction, I felt co…

5.0★Aug 2024

As a homeowner who recently rented a property through Equity Team Property Management, I am thoroughly impressed with their exceptional service. Unlike many property management companies that often treat renters as second class, Equity Team demonstrated a commendable balance in valuing renters while also protecting the homeowner's property. From the very beginning, their approach was professional and respectful. Management requests were handled promptly and efficiently. Whenever there was a concern or an issue, there was always someone available to speak with, providing a sense of reliability…

5.0★Mar 2024

Phenomenal service. Excellent communication! We are active-duty military owners and we own a single-family home. We owned our home in the Cincinnati area but were forced to relocate on military orders. We didn't want to sell so looked around at renting until we were able to return home. We found EquityTeam and could not be more impressed with the service and business model. Charity and John have been amazing from the jump. We rarely have to communicate. But when we do, it is crystal clear and it's obvious that they have my interest at heart. We have an awesome relationship and I'll be at pea…

5.0★Nov 2023

Charity was my property manager and did a phenomenal job handling my single family home rental. Invoices were always correct and she stayed on top of contractors who didn't get things done right the first time. Very thorough and incredibly professional. Equity Team is the best property management company I've used in the 8 years I've been a landlord. If you have a rental in Dayton, Equity Team should be at the top of your list for professional property management.