Ameritrue Real Estate & Management Reviews

Ameritrue Real Estate & Management logo

Ameritrue Real Estate & Management

Ameritrue Real Estate & Management, 95 W 200 N St Suite 2, Spanish Fork, UT 84660

3.7 68 verified reviews

Ameritrue specializes in managing single-family homes, townhouses, and condos across multiple states, offering hassle-free transitions and a dedicated team for property management.

Landlord vs. tenant ratings

Landlord Rating
3.7 / 5
from 10 owners
Tenant Rating
3.7 / 5
from 58 tenants
High confidence · 10 landlord reviews

Landlord Rating reflects how property owners rate this manager; Tenant Rating reflects how renters rate them. Both are 1–5 star ratings built from verified Google & Yelp reviews, weighted toward recent reviews.

Photos

Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo Ameritrue Real Estate & Management photo

Rating breakdown

5 star
86
4 star
4
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
36

Based on 126 rated reviews from the last 3 years.

Ameritrue Real Estate & Management reviews

5.0★Feb 2026

I worked with them for over a decade, and they were always responsive and professional. What I appreciate most though was the way they took care of the tenants. I heard from several of them (unsolicited) that they really felt good about their interactions with the people at Ameritrue. Even little things behind the scenes to keep things running smoothly that I wasn’t aware of till much later. They’re great, and I would work with them again.

1.0★Jan 2026

Based on my experience as a property owner, communication and follow-through was inconsistent. Over the course of one year, my tenants informed me multiple times they were unable to reach anyone at Ameriture. When I contacted the company to address this, I learned that my assigned property manager had changed 3 times without my knowledge. I was told this was due to internal turnover. During their management period, several maintenance requests outlined in the lease agreement were not completed despite assurances that they would. I was also informed that quarterly walkthroughs with photos would…

1.0★Aug 2025

This company is crooked thieves. We left the house better than we found it- it had renters in it for years and the carpets smelled awful of urine we asked them to please clean the carpets they told they were cleaned. We had them cleaned when we moved out Let me show you the fees they stole from us June equal pay utility $380 Carpet cleaning $394 House cleaning $822.50 House repairs $191.23 Equal pay utility audit $877.46 They aren’t managing the house anymore due to the owner wanting to sell. Like I said we left the house better than we found it- Communication was awful- I would avoid renting…

5.0★Apr 2025

Ameritrue has managed our property for over 10 years and have had nothing but great experiences with them. I'd sum up our experience as: peace of mind and ease!

5.0★Mar 2025

I have had an absolutely wonderful experience with Ameritrue. From the very beginning, their team has been incredibly professional, friendly, and attentive. They go above and beyond to make sure all my needs are met and that my property is well-maintained. Anytime I’ve had questions or needed assistance, they were quick to help and always offer solutions. I truly appreciate the personal touch they bring to property management– it’s obvious they genuinely care about both the property and the people. Overall, I couldn’t be more satisfied with the service they’ve provided. If you’re looking for…

5.0★Feb 2025

I’ve loved Ameritrue, they’ve been great for years! Keeps my rentals filled, tenants happy and very quick to respond when I have qs. I’ve referred several people and have only good things to say about them.

5.0★Feb 2025

Ameritrue has been managing one rental property for me for 6 years and they have made it so simple for me. Also, there has not been one month of vacancy since they have managed this property. Also, they have been responsive to problems (while keeping me in the loop) but also making sure the contract is being followed. I recommend them to anyone who ask me about my experience with a property manager.

5.0★Oct 2024

I have been with Ameritrue Property Management now for almost 3 years. I have multiple units that I have been managing for many years by myself. After being referred to Ameritrue and signing on with them, I felt a big load taken off my shoulders. All of the staff there have been great to work with. My main contacts are Jason Goodell, Susan Boyer, Kara Jarman and Deseray. I have been really pleased with their response to problems and concerns! A great Management Company

1.0★Aug 2024

Terrible management company. My property was trashed under their management. After two years under their management, my yard was destroyed, and I began to get complaints from neighbors in the neighborhood. I had to personally go out and weed and fix the yard without any reimbursement from Ameritrue..

1.0★Mar 2024

🙄 I would respond to this reply in depth but wouldn’t have the space and frankly, it’s evident based on other replies this company doesn’t take accountability for their bad practices. I will not pay a penny till the itemized statement reflects a true accurate amount.